Skip to content

Beth Solomon: Rumsfeld and Bush should have read the Abu Ghraib report

Published:

GIRL Abuse ‘un-American’? Seems to fit with policy

By Beth Solomon

F asten your seatbelts: This week’s conventional wisdom in our nation’s capital is that thousands of images of U.S. military abuses of Iraqi detainees indicate serious failures of leadership in our armed forces.

“Failure in leadership from the brigade commander on down, lack of discipline, no training whatsoever, and no supervision” were at the root of the problems, U.S. Army Gen. Antonio Taguba told the Senate in a burgeoning investigation of this scandal, finally brought to the public by Seymour Hersh of the New Yorker.

Taguba is ahead of the game. He wrote a report on the scandal trying to alert his bosses, but Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld told a Senate hearing last week that he hadn’t had time to read the whole report. What he did see of it, he never got around to mentioning to President Bush. So the president saw the photo album like the rest of us on TV.

Rummy and Bush can save time and skip the report. The message in the photos of U.S. torture and abuse is so strong, they and their policymakers might as well start their summer vacations now. And stay at the beach. U.S. foreign policy is more than understood all over the world. Remember “Baseball, mom and apple pie”? The new brand is “Beaten and maimed at Abu Ghraib.”

Response to the new foreign policy is starting to take shape. A video posted Tuesday on an Islamic militant Web site showed the beheading of an American civilian in Iraq, apparently carried out by an al-Qaeda affiliated group.

The video showed five men wearing headscarves and black ski masks, standing over a bound man in an orange jumpsuit — similar to a prisoner’s uniform. The militants wanted to shoaw that they approve of the new U.S. approach to foreign policy, and are already adopting it themselves.

“For the mothers and wives of American soldiers,” said the executioners on their Web site, “we tell you that we offered the U.S. administration to exchange this hostage with some of the detainees in Abu Ghraib and they refused.”

“So we tell you,” the statement goes on, “that the dignity of the Muslim men and women in Abu Ghraib and others is not redeemed except by blood and souls.”

It’s not comforting. But it reminds me of a concept I heard about once called “an eye for an eye.” I don’t think it was in the Koran.

The video slaughter of U.S. contractor Nick Berg was the first of more web content to come: After blowing up an Israeli troop vehicle in the Gaza strip yesterday, Palestinian militants said that they hoped to trade the soldiers’ body parts for prisoners held by Israel. On a blood-soaked sheet of brown paper, gunmen displayed for reporters what appeared to be brain matter and bits of flesh.

“They were able to take parts of bodies — hands, brains,” Salama Hamad, 32, a gunman from the group Hamas, enthusiastically told James Bennet of the New York Times.

Do they know about eBay? Secretary Rumsfeld, who pointed out that war can be “messy,” now says the images of brutality are “un-American.” By that he means they are disrespectful, humiliating and abusive. But that’s exactly what our Iraq policy has been.

What’s not American at this point is an accurate count of civilian deaths in Iraq since the beginning of the war — there is no count. And the resulting message to R.O.W. — the rest of the world — is that those numbers — those people — don’t matter.

Wait. Weren’t they the people we were trying to save?

Rumsfeld did say something about bodies. “It is a body blow when we find that we have, as we have just within the last — what — week or seven days, a few who have betrayed our values by their conduct,” Mr. Rumsfeld said. Blame it on the kids who were assigned the dirty work in Iraq.

But not everyone here agrees there should be blame placed at all. One powerful Senator, James M. Inhofe, (R-Okla.), lashed out at the controversy itself. “I’m probably not the only one up at this table that is more outraged by the outrage than we are by the treatment,” he said. While saying a few “misguided” and “maybe even perverted” perpetrators of abuse needed to be punished, much of the criticism, Inhofe said, was exaggerated and misplaced.

Democracy, dissent, speaking out against our government? To some in this city, that’s what you call a capital offense. (Beth Solomon is a Left Coast writer reachable at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 12, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe