Skip to content

Column: Despite weak July payroll numbers, economy is quietly creating jobs

Published:

Don’t count the economy out before it’s hatched

By BETH SOLOMON

WASHINGTON — Some Democrats are gleeful that recent U.S. job statistics were grim. Bush administration officials, hearing news that nonfarm payroll jobs increased by just 32,000 in July — one-sixth the amount predicted by economists — were sullen.

But John Kerry supporters should put the breaks on their shadenfreude and Republicans have reason to smile: A deeper look at the statistics shows that the economy is quietly surging forward — and creating jobs.

Here’s how it works. The 32,000 figure represents a piece in a much larger puzzle. The Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor produces two sets of job counts each month. One is the Establishment (Payroll) Survey, the other is the Household Survey. The payroll survey takes data from employers, the household survey measures things from the perspective of job seekers. In July, as the payroll survey reported a disappointing 32,000 jobs created, the household survey reported 629,000 new jobs.

This strange phenomenon didn’t start in July. Since November 2001, the payroll survey shows 401,000 new jobs created. The household survey shows 3.2 million.

How can this be? The reason is that the payroll survey does not measure the self-employed, the entrepreneurs, the people who don’t get measured by broad-sweeping government counts. The payroll survey does not count any employed person not registered with a state unemployment insurance system. Are you registered? Do you even know?

As technology makes it easier to start a business, to earn money as a consultant, to sell things across state lines, more people are operating as entrepreneurs, fitting nimbly into a quickly changing economy. That’s good. But it’s harder to measure. Those people don’t get counted when traditional job statistics are gathered.

How is the economy really doing? Here are some more statistics: In the second quarter, Gross Domestic Product growth was 3 percent. This news was greeted with disappointment — it was less than expected. But at the same time, the government revised its measure of first quarter growth. Instead of showing 3.9 percent expansion, the economy really grew at 4.5 percent. That’s a big difference. By comparison, growth during the Clinton administration averaged 3.7 percent.

On another front, exports grew at a rate of 18.4 percent during the second quarter when job growth looked so grim. Business-fixed investment jumped almost 9 percent for its fifth straight quarter of growth. Experts say this means that companies are expanding — and willing to take risks to be competitive.

The truth is, the burst of the stock market bubble at the end of the Clinton administration caused a cyclical downturn. Businesses retracted. Because income had risen and tax rates remained the same, the net revenues flowing out of business and into government hands increased. Some economists say this amounted to a de facto tax hike.

The first Bush tax cut in 2001, called “temporary,” didn’t turn things around. But the second round of tax cuts in 2003 immediately resulted in higher rates of business investment. Economists say reductions in capital gains and dividend tax rates spurred entrepreneurial activity by encouraging risk-taking. Since that time, business-fixed investment is up 13 percent.

We’re not out of the woods yet. Oil prices are haywire — and climbing rapidly. Anything can happen in Iraq and the Middle East. Congress just passed one of the largest defense budgets in history, siphoning money away from more direct investment in our economy and taking funds away from long-term needs like education that make our country strong.

But nobody should pounce on a single jobs statistic with too much confidence that it supports their economic ideology.

And no one should underestimate the savvy Bush administration when it comes to economic growth, and optimism. (Beth Solomon is reachable at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 13, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe