City Council member Dan Hall said that, now that Measure ES failed, the City has some difficult choices. Why? Because they counted their chickens before they hatched. Why would the City plan on a new tax passing that its own polling showed didn’t have enough support, except to pressure residents to vote for the new tax?
Why is $12 million such an issue when spending $60 million and creating new ongoing expenses of $23 million for the Realignment Plan was done in the blink of an eye? That decision was made in one City Council meeting, with no details on how the $60 million would be spent, and no details as to what the ongoing $23 million was.
Most people think that $60 million is going to address public safety, clean streets, housing, and economic growth. In reality, much of the cost is going to new staff, executive and staff equity increases (before the compensation survey is completed), and additional staff benefits, including 7 extra vacation days for the winter closure, 2% of personnel costs to provide non-sworn staff with increased medical coverage, and a $100 per year wellness reimbursement benefit. Despite a Public Records Act Request, the City won’t release what the estimate was for the cost of the winter closure.
What business school teaches that after declaring fiscal distress, you should go and hire 143 staff and give equity increases and additional benefits? Most other cities, including Santa Monica in 2002, cut staff after declaring fiscal distress.
For the new revenues identified, the vast majority of that revenue isn't related to what the $60 million was being spent on. It was increasing parking, user, and credit card fees for a total of $13.5 million. Plus $1 million in increased interest, $6 million in staff vacancy management, and $1.4 million in increased traffic citations and fire inspections. They specifically chose not to include any improved economic growth revenues, including any bumps from FIFA, the Super Bowl, or the 2028 Olympics.
The City initially “contemplated” a parcel tax to replace the $12 million of Joint Use Agreement (JUA) funding. The City included not paying the $12 million JUA payment in the Realignment Plan using obscure language of “projections also reflect the options that exist with regard to the Joint Use Agreement with SMMUSD (~$12M/yr set to expire in 2027)”.
By not including the new economic growth in last year’s budget, the City ended up $8 million better than they had predicted. If the Realignment Plan is as successful as the Mayor says, there should be even more this year and more in 2027-28. That should easily cover the $12 million if the City decides to renew the Joint Use Agreement at the current rate for the 2027-28 budget.
The City started giving the School District money when the City was rich, and the District was poor. Now that the tables are turned, the School District should help the City out and do something like split the difference at least temporarily. $6 million more than covers the fair market value of the use of the elementary and middle school after-school access.
But won’t a decrease of $6 million to schools mean that 36 teachers would need to be let go? Only if classroom teachers are the last priority instead of being what they should be: the highest priority and last to be identified for layoffs. IF layoffs were required, it should be of non-classroom staff who have increased by 9%, including multiple new executive positions, while enrollment has decreased by 23%. Layoffs should not be required at all, as the District has averaged a $13 million surplus over the last 6 years while predicting an average of a $5 million deficit, and reserves are at record levels.
The predicted deficits for the future years are gamesmanship, strategically underestimating revenues to paint a bleak picture to help get taxes passed and to negotiate lower increases for teachers and staff under the guise of being conservative. If a private sector CFO told their CEO in May that they would end the year in June with a $9 million deficit but then end up the year with an $8 million surplus, they’d be fired for being so far off. The explanation by the District as to the difference included most things that should have been known in May, making the May 2026 budget presentation suspect. I give the District credit for having timely budget updates and final financial reports, unlike the City.
In order to get philanthropic funding for the Great Park, the City needs to provide timely, reliable, and transparent financial information. Not getting the details for the 2025-26 fiscal year until March 2027 and June 2027 does not cut it. Not getting detailed budget updates during the year doesn’t cut it. Not having a financial data portal for the City’s past financial data doesn’t cut it. Not having details yet on the 2027-28 fiscal year budget and additional future years doesn’t cut it.
The City’s financial processes and transparency need to be significantly improved to provide information to the City’s residents, businesses, and potential philanthropic donors. Best practices include quarterly budget updates and a rolling 5-year financial forecast that models best-case, expected, and downturn scenarios. Stop playing games and provide sound and transparent financial management and reporting.
Karen Melick