Skip to content

Prepare for a close race, contact politics, photo finish

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

Labor Day has passed, and both presidential campaigns are in full swing. The four-year marathons have turned into 60-day sprints. This also is when campaigns take a nasty turn, and most voters lose their taste for politics.

Like clockwork, the candidates — desperation increasing — sharpen their messages and hit the road, using every weapon in their arsenal to make voters see the differences between themselves and their opponents. The closer the election, the nastier it gets.

This isn’t such a bad thing. If you like boxing, ice hockey or football, politics can be as fun to watch as any competitive contact sport (“It ain’t bean bag”), and the stakes are much more significant, which makes participating all the more exciting (“Politics is the only true game for adults”).

For those of you who believe that politics should be nice, all I can tell you is that (a) politics has never been nice — it’s about conflict, and (b) negative campaigning is much tamer today than it was in times past — people used to engage in duels, for goodness sake.

The only bad part is that a lot of people who got excited about participating in what they think is the noble democratic process are surprised by the mudslinging. Unlike reformers who complain about the negativity, these people are stunned by the crudeness of it all. By Election Day, their idealism has turned to cynicism, and they decide not to vote because neither candidate seems worthy of the effort.

When this happens, overall turnout decreases, and the election is largely left up to the partisans, those rare people who feel they belong to a political party, and who do not vote “for the candidate,” or “on the issue,” but because it is “their duty.”

The race between Bush and Kerry is following on this trajectory. It’s already close, and it’s getting fierce. Despite the record number of people who’ve been paying attention, it’s likely that by November, many won’t turn out because they’ll have been turned off.

We could end up very nearly approximating, if not duplicating, the results of the last election. The difference being that Electoral College shifts (due to reapportionment) and some key Senate races could make Colorado and Louisiana more important than Florida.

How? Imagine Bush wins all the same states he did before, and Kerry wins all of the states that Gore won in 2000. Bush would win the election (278 to 260). But if one state, Colorado, switches and goes for Kerry, instead of Bush, the outcome is a tie (269 to 269).

According to the Constitution, a tie sends the decision to the newly sworn-in House of Representatives (each state delegation gets one vote). With the Republicans currently in the majority in 30 state delegations and the Democrats not able to change the distribution much in this election, a tie would still “reelect” Bush.

But the vice presidential decision (since the 12th Amendment to the Constitution) rests with the Senate, not the House. The Democrats could win back the Senate majority and elect John Edwards to serve as vice president in a Bush Administration.

Repeat after me: This is not a Hollywood movie.

Though it may feel like one because the drama could play out over a month past the election, if Louisiana’s Senate race goes to a runoff, which is not at all improbable.

Louisiana holds its primary on the day of the general election. As a result, there are four major party candidates (one Republican and three Democrats) running for Senate. Their election law says that one of them must get a majority (50, plus 1) to win, and in a race with four candidates that is extremely difficult. More likely, the Republican David Vitter and the Democrat Chris John will go into a runoff election, and the winner won’t be determined until Dec. 4, 2004.

Should the Democratic majority in the Senate depend on the outcome of the Louisiana Senate race, you can expect wall-to-wall coverage from Nov. 3 to Dec. 4. If the presidential election ends in an Electoral College vote tie, party competition will reach an all-time high (or low, depending on your perspective).

HERE’S THE THING: Politics is a contact sport, and it should come as no surprise that candidates and campaigns get dirty late in the game. Like football teams, they use hurry-up offensives to try to score, while their defensives blitz and tackle hoping for a sack, and if they’re lucky, a turnover.

While the closeness of this election means it might get ugly, it’s also going to provide for the possibility of a photo finish — now is not the time to tune out, you might regret it later. Anyone remember the “Heidi” game? (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles and is teaching this semester in Arkansas, at Hendrix College and UALR. She).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 9, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe