Skip to content

President’s so-called plan will put seniors in squalor

Published:

By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN

For anyone who has read a newspaper or watched the news during the past decade or so, it’s no secret that Social Security is in trouble. Politicians have been griping and doing nothing about it for years. In fact, the only one who seemed surprised by the Social Security “crisis” was our president, George W. Bush.

For the past four years in office Bush slashed taxes, gave away hundreds of billions to big business, racked up record deficits and squandered the Clinton Administration’s surplus that, according to ex-Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill and Federal Reserve Chairman Allan Green-span, would have rescued Social Security. And it’s only now that the president has suddenly realized that one of America’s most popular, successful and compassionate programs is going bankrupt.

The problem is that, like the president’s promise that tax cuts would not cause deficits, Bush is not being completely honest.

Even if we do nothing, Social Security can continue to pay full benefits until at least 2042. After that, according to Arkansas’ Times Record, they could continue to pay 70 percent benefits indefinitely. Medicare, on the other hand, will become insolvent in 2019.

So why isn’t the president more concerned about Medicare? To understand, you need to look at the President’s Social Security scheme.

Though the exact details have yet to be announced, most agree that the Bush plan would include modest — at first, then drastic — benefit reductions for younger workers, which could mean those as old as 55. Further, these younger workers would be allowed to divert some of their Social Security payroll taxes into individual investment accounts. The Administration’s argument is that the stock market produces a better return than the government.

Of course, the first question that comes to mind is that if the returns from equity markets are so wonderful, why not allow the Social Security Administration to invest that same portion of funds, which they could do far more cost effectively than individuals, and save our current system?

The answer is that saving Social Security is not what Bush, Republicans or master strategist Karl Rove have in mind. What they are really after is … making more republicans.

“The sky is falling, the sky is falling.” — Yes, Bush is once again running around like Chicken Little proclaiming the end is near. No, we are not under threat of being blown up, gassed or infected by Iraq’s (imaginary) WMDs. This time W’s big lie is about Social Security

Their theory is that if more Americans have their financial security tied up in stocks, then they will embrace Republican values. Not only will this extend the Republican dynasty, but it will make it far easier for neoconservative Republicans to embrace the President’s pro-corporate agenda of eliminating pesky environmental protections, workplace safety regulations and class action suits, not to mention outsourcing more American jobs.

Of course, the President’s plan does nothing to address the biggest threat facing our nation’s financial security, the massive national debt. In fact, it will add as much as $2 trillion to the already bloated deficit. This will decimate the next generation and could ultimately wreak havoc on the stock market, thus undermining the president’s plan.

Even if the debt were not a major concern, there is no guarantee that the stock market will continue to perform as well as it has in the past and much evidence, such as the sinking dollar, record trade deficits, slower growth projections and the explosion of the Asian economy, that suggest that it will not.

The market also is susceptible to extended downturns, and has from time to time lost a large percentage of its value. If you happen to retire at such a time the result could be devastating.

Corporate scandals and rapidly changing technology also could impact retirees. Just imagine if the bulk of your investments had been distributed between such A-list companies as Enron, Lucent, AT&T, WorldCom, K-Mart and Tyco.

And, if the administration’s dire predictions are correct, the United States will eventually become the victim of a nuclear terrorist attack. Such an attack, even with little damage and loss of life, would have a catastrophic effect on equity markets.

Of course, the president could easily save Social Security with his support of raising salary caps on contributions, canceling the latest corporate tax giveaways, eliminating subsidies for giant agriculture conglomerates and rolling back tax cuts on the wealthiest 2 percent of Americans. But don’t hold your breath.

And don’t be surprised — if Bush and his corporate conspirators have their way — if you someday see millions of Senior Americans living in squalor, forced to work until the day they die or even living on the streets. In other words, just like it was before Social Security.

Of course, if that happens, there’ll be a lot more Democrats. (Comments or requests for copies of this column can be e-mailed to).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 19, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe