By Ed Silverstein
It is appalling, not to mention illegal, that our government will likely allow Newscorp to purchase DirecTV. It is not, however, the least bit surprising.
Along with the FCC’s attempt to ease constraints on media ownership, this is one of several recent Bush Administration gambits to consolidate media ownership in the hands of a few supportive mega-conglomerates. But even among these media empires, Rupert Murdoch’s Newscorp is Bush’s No. 1 cheerleader.
Murdoch has transformed Fox News — featuring a lineup of right-wing pundits that often seem like nothing more than a horde of Bush press secretaries — into the Al Jazeera of the Republican Party. Their coverage of Republicans, in particular Bush, is as critical as my grandmother’s review of my playing a major food group in my second-grade play. But just put a Democrat on the screen, and Fox suddenly mutates into something akin to Erin Brockovich critiquing toxic sludge.
But this is nothing new. Murdoch has a long history of using his media-empire muscle to bolster politicians willing to further his aims. In England, he heavily endorsed both Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and John Major who, in turn, helped lift restrictions on media ownership. For their efforts, Thatcher and Major were both rewarded with seven-figure book contracts from Newscorp’s HarperCollins Publishing, even though there was little chance that the money would be recouped. And Tony Blair is following right in their footsteps.
And here in America, Newt Gingrich, upon ushering legislation through Congress that eased ownership rules and gave Newscorp a $400 million tax break, received an extremely generous $4.5 million advance on his autobiography from HarperCollins. Though the outcry forced Newt to return most of the money, the ex- Speaker more than made up for the loss as an on-air commentator for Fox.
Murdoch controls a lion’s share of the media in England and Australia, and now his sights are set on the United States. Newscorp already owns Fox Television Network, Fox News, Twentieth Century Fox, Fox Sports, the New York Post, TV Guide, HarperCollins Publishing and an assortment of television stations and magazines. And soon he hopes to add the country’s leading deliverer of television programming, DirecTV, to his portfolio.
Let’s forget for a minute that it is illegal for a non-American company— Newscorp is Australian — to own a U.S. network or television station, a fact that has been conveniently overlooked by the Republican-controlled FCC. The larger issue is that Rupert Murdoch has the ethics of a Baghdad rug merchant and can not be trusted.
HarperCollins, for example, canceled a book by former Hong Kong governor Chris Patten that was critical of the Chinese leadership in order to get the Chinese government to allow him to provide satellite service.
When he wanted to expand those broadcasting ventures, he gave Deng Xiaoping's daughter a $1 million-plus HarperCollins book bribe for a fawning and commercially nonviable propaganda piece on her father. Then he removed the BBC World Service from his satellite system in China because the authorities did not like a program that the BBC aired about Mao Tse-tung.
Murdoch further demonstrated the extremes to which he is willing to go with Fox’s participation in the subversion of the 2000 presidential election. This supposedly fair-and-balanced station had its president and founder, Roger Ailes, coach Bush for the presidential debates. In a shameless conflict of interest, “W’s” cousin, working at Fox, called the election for Bush without any conclusive data. During the ensuing controversy, Fox News supported every draconian scheme by Republican operatives to prevent the recount while lambasting all of Gore’s legitimate concerns.
But don’t for a minute believe there is any loyalty to Bush or the United States. If it meant expanding his empire, Murdoch would sell out U.S. interests faster than you can say North Korea (or for that matter Syria, Iran or even Iraq) This sale should not be permitted. With the FCC beholden to Bush, it is up to Congress to ensure that we maintain a free and independent media by stopping this purveyor of yellow journalism. The alternative could very well be 500 channels with nothing except Fox News and reruns of Skin.
Sources: Columbia Journalism Review, What Liberal Media, by Eric Alterman. For comprehensive information on Fox News bias go to: www.fair.org/extra/0108/fox-main.html (Ed Silverstein is a free-lance writer living in Santa Monica. He would like to apologize to all Baghdad rug merchants for unfairly impeaching them through a comparison to Rupert Murdoch. Comments can be e-mailed to)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 10, 2003. Read the original PDF.