Skip to content

Prop. 77: A guide for the curious

Published:

By Charles Berry Mendocino, Calif.

The advertisements opposing Proposition 77 are so duplicitous, disingenuous and divorced from the proposed text, it is amazing that a substantial minority is planning to vote for it. The political fog which surrounds the opposition to 77 depends on voters who have not studied it. It is not a perfect document, but is a very worthy one, and deserves a few minutes of your time.

Gerrymandering is the practice of designing Assembly, State Senate, or congressional districts so that only a member of one particular party can win there. California is thoroughly gerrymandered: not a single one of these districts changed party in the most recent elections. Therefore, the representatives of these districts worry very little about being unseated. Therefore, the representatives of these districts are less attentive to the needs of the voters in their districts.

Proposition 77 is designed to end gerrymandering by taking the power to make district boundaries away from the Legislature, and giving it to three retired judges. These three judges must survive several steps designed to ensure that the boundary plan they produce is as unbiased as is humanly possible (contrary to the utterly false assertions of several political ads). First, the initial pool of 24 judges must be balanced between Republicans and Democrats. Second, the pool is reduced to 12 as each of the four legislative leaders (two Republican, two Democrat) gets to nominate three of these judges for further consideration, but the judges picked by each of these four must be from a party different from his or her own. That is, the two Republicans can’t pick Republicans, and the two Democrats can’t pick Democrats. This step alone will remove most bias, but the protections don’t stop there. Next, each of these four leaders gets to remove one of the nominated 12 (thereby leaving eight judges), making the possibility of a biased remaining judge even more remote. From these eight, the final three judges are drawn by lot, and each of the two major parties must be represented. Ex parte communications are restricted, public hearings must be held, the effect of the plan on current legislators and parties must be disregarded, the selection of any plan must be unanimous, the plan must produce districts which are contiguous, compact and follow existing city and county lines to the extent practicable. Finally, the voters get to approve or disapprove the plan selected, after its first use.

If you think gerrymandering is a serious problem, and if these protections against bias are satisfactory to you, Proposition 77 deserves your vote.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 5, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe