By Tom Larmore Santa Monica
Ken Breisch apparently believes that Proposition A should be opposed because the United States Supreme Court upheld the validity of New York City's landmarks ordinance in the 1978 case of Penn Central Transportation v. New York City (SMDP letters, March 8). Ken's argument is, however, entirely beside the point.
First, just because the Supreme Court has upheld the validity of a law doesn't meant the decision, or the law, is right — remember “separate but equal” in Plessy v. Ferguson?
Second, Ken should remember that Penn Central dealt with a commercial building — Grand Central Station in New York — not with individual homes. And the New York ordinance, unlike Santa Monica's, included a method of compensating the landowner for the value of what was lost as a result of the landmark status.
Third, and most importantly, the campaign to pass Proposition A has nothing to do with the constitutionality, or lack of same, of the city's landmarks ordinance — it has to do with its lack of basic fairness.
I do not believe I have a right to tell my neighbors that they must leave their homes the way they are simply because I think they have such historical or architectural significance that they should be preserved. And because I don't think I should have that power, I don't think I have the right to give the city bureaucracy that same power.
I have no quarrel with the notion that historic preservation programs, when properly administered, can enhance the community's quality of life. I just don't think I have the right to enhance my quality of life over the backs of my neighbors by subjecting them to restrictions not applicable to all of us.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 10, 2003. Read the original PDF.