Skip to content

Proposed legislation

Published:

permitting assisted suicide threatened

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY THOMAS A. BOWDEN

John Ashcroft may have resigned from the Justice Department, but the former Attorney General’s conservative legacy lives on in a lawsuit that threatens to scuttle Vermont’s chances of enacting a physician-assisted suicide bill.

The pending Vermont bills are modeled on an Oregon law that permits physicians to prescribe a lethal dose of drugs to a mentally competent, terminally ill patient who makes written and oral requests, consults two doctors, and endures a mandatory waiting period.

Back in 2001, Ashcroft decreed that any doctor prescribing such a dose would violate federal law against dispensing controlled dangerous substances without a “legitimate medical purpose.” So far, Ashcroft’s position has been rejected by the courts, but the Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case, and an adverse outcome would doom Vermont’s budding legislation.

The real issue, however, is not whether medicine should be controlled by federal government or the states. Rather, the issue is whether an individual has a right to commit suicide.

Hopefully, the Supreme Court will revisit its 1997 decision in Washington vs. Glucksberg, which held that individuals have no constitutionally protected right of suicide, and hence no right to obtain assistance in that act. The Glucksberg case looks increasingly vulnerable to being overruled, especially in light of the legal uncertainties surrounding Terri Schiavo’s death and the court’s newfound willingness to uphold individual rights, as demonstrated in its 2003 decision decriminalizing private homosexual acts despite objections from religionists.

What the courts must grasp, if they are to justly resolve the debate over assisted suicide, is that there is no rational, secular basis upon which the government can properly prevent any individual from choosing to end his own life. Rather, it is religious mysticism that energizes the Bush administration into intimidating doctors who dare to defy God’s divine plan.

The conservatives’ outrage at the Oregon law stems from the belief that human life is a gift from the Lord, who puts us here on earth to carry out His will. Thus, the very idea of suicide is anathema, because one who “plays God” by causing his own death, or assisting in the death of another, insults his Maker and invites eternal damnation, not to mention divine retribution against the decadent society that permits such sinful behavior.

When religious conservatives use secular laws to enforce their faith in God, they threaten the central principle on which America was founded. The Declaration of Independence proclaimed, for the first time in the history of nations, that each person exists as an end in himself. This basic truth — which finds political expression in the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness — means, in practical terms, that you need no one's permission to live, and that no one may forcibly obstruct your efforts to achieve your own personal happiness.

But what if happiness becomes impossible to attain? What if a dread disease, or some other calamity, drains all joy from life, leaving only misery and suffering? The right to life includes and implies the right to commit suicide. To hold otherwise — to declare that society or God must give you permission to kill yourself — is to contradict the right to life at its root. If you have a duty to go on living, despite your better judgment, then your life does not belong to you, and you exist by permission, not by right.

For these reasons, each individual has the right to decide the hour of his death and to implement that solemn decision as best he can. The choice is his because the life is his. And if a doctor is willing to assist in the suicide, based on an objective assessment of his patient's mental and physical state, the law should not stand in his way.

If George W. Bush were to contract a terminal disease, he would have a legal right to regard his own faith in God’s will as paramount, and to instruct his doctor to stand by and let him suffer, just as long as his body and mind could endure the agony, until the last bitter paroxysm carried him to the grave. But the Bush administration has no right to force such mindless, medieval misery upon doctors and patients in Oregon, Vermont or elsewhere, who refuse to regard their precious lives as playthings of a cruel God.

In the end, only the Supreme Court can thwart the designs of conservatives who, by injecting religion into the bloodstream of American law, seek to assist in our own national suicide. (Thomas A. Bowden is an attorney and a writer for Ayn Rand Institute in Irvine. The institute promotes the ideas of Ayn Rand, best-selling author of “Atlas Shrugged” and “The Fountainhead” and originator of the philosophy of Objectivism.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 9, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe