By Joshua M. Pelzer Pasadena
It’s hard to imagine how any citizen who values their constitutional right to vote, would be anything but ecstatic about passing Proposition 77.
Why? Because if the measure passes, it would mean a voter’s voice actually counts for something again. It would end the legislature’s power to pick its voters by manipulating electoral districts and preventing voters from having real choices at the ballot box, thereby making the act of voting little more than a trivial waste of time.
The consequences are real. Of the 153 congressional and state legislative races last November, not one incumbent faced defeat. This was not an accident, but rather a planned result through collusion and manipulation of the electoral system.
We expect this from third-world despots and totalitarian regimes, not from what is supposed to be the planet’s greatest democracy. The whole practice stinks of the desperate need for reform, which is too long overdue. Proposition 77 does that by taking that power out of the hands of those who stand to benefit and turns it over to a panel of three impartial judges selected by the Legislature. Districts would become competitive with election results dependent upon an elected official’s accountability to the voters rather than winks and handshakes in the protected halls of the legislature.
The argument that this is a Democrat versus Republican issue doesn’t stand since both sides play and benefit from the same game. It’s as much a conflict of interest as it is detrimental to the health of our government, but it continues because citizens just don’t seem to care. Well, when California hits rock bottom, maybe they will.
And anyone who takes the time to educate themselves on Proposition 75 will see that the measure is pro-union, despite what we are hearing from its leadership. Proposition 75 empowers organized labor by requiring that permission from public employee union members be obtained before dues can be spent on political activities. It gives members a stronger voice with more control over how their dues are spent when financing political activities that they may or may not agree with, plain and simple. It also protects them from having their role in the union diminished when they voice grievances that go against the interests of their leadership.
How is labor being silenced when employees are given a stronger voice in their cause, more choice in how dues are spent, and more accountability from their leaders? This proposition does nothing to stop spending from public employee unions. It simply requires them to ask for donations rather than raiding employee paychecks for political activities without consent. Members who don’t support their leadership’s agenda should not be forced to finance it. Proposition 75 doesn’t silence organized labor, it protects it.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 5, 2005. Read the original PDF.