By Ben Jacobs Save the Sand Committee, Santa Monica
Dog activists ask ours and other communities to just “try” an unfenced, unleashed free-roaming dog beach. They ask us to try this potentially disastrous experiment based on us believing facts that purports to be true, but upon closer inspection, are highly dubious. They ask us to believe that all current dog beaches are clean, safe, supported wholly by the community and their representatives, are environmentally sound, are not a threat to native wildlife and are welcomed by everyone.
The dog activists make assumptions not based on scientific fact but hearsay, half-truths and false statistics, which are either well-intentioned delusions or selfish manipulations to further the dog activists’ agenda at the expense and welfare of the entire community.
A few points: ■ Dog defecation is going to happen on the beach. No matter how much the “volunteers” claim they will keep fecal and urine out of the sand everyone knows this is an impossible task. This tainted and soiled sand will make its way into the ocean or onto someone’s body either through swimming or picked up or swallowed particularly by a child. ■ The potential for dog bites is huge, particularly in the areas proposed in Santa Monica and El Segundo. The recent escalation of dog maulings in Los Angeles with a child recently being killed by an unleashed household dog that everyone said was “very friendly,” illustrates the unpredictable nature of unleashed dogs no matter their supervision. ■ AB 359 was effectively defeated this year in the California State Senate after representatives led by State Sen. Sheila Kuehl, actually saw what this measure would do and its effect on the environment (http://info.sen.ca.gov/pub/bill/- asm/ab_03510400/ab_359_cfa_20050628_162811_sen_comm.html_). ■ Dog activists cite the full support of the Los Angeles City Council of AB 359 but fail to mention not one of the council members could have seen the actual area proposed — a one-mile stretch of beach where an aquatic youth center is to be built — as they listed it as Playa del Rey not El Segundo. ■ Dog volunteers cannot keep away the bad apples. We can just see Georja Umano, the president of Unleash the Beach, and other dog activists, with their whistles and neon vests shooing away gang members, out-of-town rotweiler and pit bull owners and irresponsible dog poopers from the sand and water — then calling for help from the lifeguards or police. ■ A recent article in the outdoor section of the LA Times (www.latimes.com/travel/outdoors) with respect to unleashed dogs becoming a huge problem on trails and in our parks, illustrates the predatory nature of even the nicest canine, especially to threatened species such as the endangered Snowy Plover, which makes its nests in the proposed dog beach areas. ■ It is every California citizen’s constitutional right to enjoy safe and free open access to any public beach in this state? We do not want “volunteers” to tell us not to swim or recreate along with our children through the dog beach zone for fear of our health and safety.
For the above reasons and many others, we cannot let our beaches become dangerous experiments for an elite group. Please join LA County Beaches and Harbors, Department of Parks and Recreation, the Surfrider Foundation, the Audubon Society, Heal the Bay, Natural Resources Defense Council, Defenders of Wildlife and thousands of environmentalists, beach goers and responsible dog owners, and urge your representatives to oppose any legislation that would explore an unleashed, unfenced, free-roaming dog beach along the Santa Monica Bay zone.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 19, 2005. Read the original PDF.