Skip to content

Race to the White House begins with the basics

Published:

By Lara M. Brown, Ph.D.

D espite what you’ve seen on the news, President Bush still has the advantage. He’s the incumbent. Our country tends to like change in theory, much more than we like it in fact.

Since 1900, we’ve had 11 presidential elections where an incumbent who won the office (rather than assuming it after a death or a resignation) ran for reelection. Only three times has a challenger beat the sitting president — Roosevelt over Hoover; Reagan over Carter; and Clinton over Bush. Not impossible, just improbable. To win, you have to be exceptional.

These presidents (Roosevelt, Reagan and Clinton) are considered by historians to be some of the great communicators — extraordinary rhetorical skills coupled with an ability to relate to people. They listened, empathized, reassured, and persuaded large enough coalitions to get not only elected, but also reelected. It’s no accident.

The presidency is an office of survival of the fittest, not survival of the best, wisest or most qualified person. It’s the person who is most able to articulate a vision and connect with the public — the best politician.

All sorts of things factor into whether or not specific candidates have more success than others at certain times in history, but the basic political skills of the nominee have to be there. No amount of packaging by the campaigns can make up for it.

Democrats during the primaries told pollsters that “electabilty” was the only trait that mattered in a candidate. Most felt that Sen. John Kerry, given his political experience and distinguished resume, would be the best nominee. Many were willing to overlook his tendency towards long-winded responses. Many believed his biography would overcome his personality.

While the polls are close about who will win (Bush and Kerry are within a few points of each other), Kerry’s numbers suggest that his campaign’s hopes of creating a favorable impression among voters with a $27.5 million television advertising buy may soon be dashed.

The New York Times/CBS News Poll, conducted from April 23-27, places the percentage of voters who hold a favorable opinion of Kerry at 27 percent, while 33 percent hold an unfavorable opinion. Twenty-six percent are undecided and 14 percent feel they haven’t heard enough to form an opinion. The same poll taken four months earlier, Jan. 12-15, is markedly different. Back then 19 percent had a favorable opinion of Kerry, 15 percent an unfavorable opinion, 27 percent were undecided, and 38 percent did not have enough information.

It is not usual that as a candidate becomes more known, his “unfavorables” rise. But what is disconcerting is the proportion of voters Kerry seems to be winning versus losing (8 percent favorable versus 18 percent unfavorable). These shifts led to the 25 percent decrease in those who were undecided or needed more information, which means that the pool of voters who are open to receiving the advertisements’ message is shrinking. While 40 percent have yet to form an opinion, if the “likeability” proportion stays the same, Kerry can only expect his “favorables” to increase about 18 percent, while his “unfavorables” will rise about 22 percent. In short, were Kerry better known, he would not necessarily be better liked. His numbers might settle somewhere close to 45 percent favorable and 51 percent unfavorable.

President Bush — well known as the incumbent — has relatively stable numbers. In April, 38 percent perceived him favorably, 43 percent perceived him unfavorably, 18 percent were undecided, and only 1 percent felt they hadn’t heard enough. In January, 41 percent held a favorable opinion of Bush, 38 percent held an unfavorable opinion, 16 percent were undecided, and 4 percent hadn’t heard enough (margins of error +/- 3 percent).

A Granite State Poll conducted in April by researchers at the University of New Hampshire mirrors the above projections. Kerry is well known in New Hampshire, being both a neighbor and having just run an intensive primary campaign in the state. As a result, 46 percent of likely voters hold favorable opinions of him, 42 percent unfavorable, 10 percent are neutral, and 2 percent feel they need more information.

Yet Kerry’s numbers are worsening at a more rapid rate than Bush’s. In February, 59 percent of likely voters held a favorable opinion of Kerry (13 percent decrease from April), 32 percent held an unfavorable opinion (10 percent increase), and 7 percent were neutral, while 2 percent felt that they needed more information. Conversely, in February, 47 percent held favorable opinions of Bush, 49 percent unfavorable, and 4 percent were neutral; and in April 49 percent held favorable opinions of Bush, 47 percent were unfavorable, and 4 percent were neutral (margins of error +/- 4.4 percent).

Here’s The Thing: Kerry needs to focus on his communication and people skills — not just issue positions. Advertisements won’t do it. Maybe when he comes to Los Angeles, instead of solely raising money, he might consider taking an acting class. Maybe Governor Schwarzenegger would agree to private lessons. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is an education policy consultant and a visiting scholar at UCLA’s Institute for Social Science Research. She).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 6, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe