LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
By Neil Macaulay Santa Monica
Jerry Rubin writes (SMDP, Sept. 30, page 4) that he’d like to see smoking banned in Santa Monica outdoor dining areas. Has he nothing else in his life to worry about except trivialities like this? I should have thought a person dining outside in Santa Monica would be more upset by filthy men leaning over his table and begging — the height of bad manners, if nothing else — or the god-awful racket of some idiot banging on plastic buckets.
You have thousands of cars belching exhaust fumes all the time. The air is heavily polluted by that. It’s ludicrous to say that cigarette smoke is a problem in air like this. It’s a tiny drop in the ocean of car polluted air. My window sills at home are constantly filthy with the black dust from the air outside which comes from car exhausts. When I went to the restaurant, I walked or took a bus, polluting no one. When the average non-smoker drives to a restaurant, his car deposited more filth and pollutants into the air, which I breathe, than a smoker does in a lifetime. This is selective morality. Look at this bad smoker with his few whiffs of smoke, but don’t look at the huge filth my car has belched out.
If Mr. Rubin wants a cause to champion he would do better to mount a campaign against obesity. Far more people are going to die because of excessive eating rather than excessive smoking. In my opinion, a person who eats moderately and smokes occasionally is going to be healthier than someone who eats excessively and doesn’t smoke. I think the percentage of the population that smokes is down to about 25 percent and they are hardcore. They are not going to stop. But over 50 percent of the population, including kids, is overweight or obese. So the new battle is against obesity. The battle against smoking is won. Jerry finds smoking outside offensive. I find the sight of overweight people eating outside offensive. It puts me off my food. I don’t mean any disrespect to anyone who is overweight for reasons beyond their control, but most people have control over what they eat.
It seems Santa Monica passes more and more laws against respectable working people who have worked hard all day and want to relax with a cigarette at the end of the day, and ignores the enforcement of laws against layabouts who haven’t done a stroke of work all day. Why? Because respectable hard working people will obey the laws and layabouts won’t. In a Santa Monica City Council meeting, an advocate for the latest smoking ban said that there would be little or no cost for law enforcement because smoking bans are self-enforcing. In other words, smokers are such well behaved, solid citizens that they will obey the law without question or being policed.
Although it is true that excessive smoking will cause cancer, many smokers have the good sense to not smoke excessively and do not get cancer. It’s nonsense to suggest that everyone who smokes will get cancer. The biggest nonsense is to suggest that side smoke is going to harm a non-smoker’s health. Where is the statistically valid study which says so? Has Mr. Rubin read it in its entirety? We constantly get references in the news media to studies, but who has ever seen the study? Who has ever read it? What does it really say exactly? How big was the sample? How reliable is the organization which did the study? What is their degree of confidence in the results? Statistics is just a pragmatic science — it is not the word of God. It just consists of taking a very small sample of a population and hoping that the results of a study are applicable to the entire population. Sometimes they get it wrong. All we get in the media is some paraphrasing of the result — blown up to be as alarmist as possible. During childhood, my parents smoked like chimneys. When I was a teenager, I worked as a waiter in an English pub where everyone smoked and the smoke was so dense that tears ran down my face on the first night. If there were any truth whatsoever in these silly so-called studies which say side smoke is dangerous, I would have been dead before I was 7 years old. I’m still alive and far more healthy than the average person of my age. It’s time for people to use their common sense and life experience and stop being hoodwinked by all these misleading studies.
Those who advocate the eternally increasing number of bans are very underhand in their approach. They got their original draconian ban on indoor smoking by saying that smokers could just sit outside. Now that they have gained a beach head they want to ban smoking outside as well. This is just pure bloody mindedness.
It’s time for smokers to stop letting themselves be walked over. They have a right to smoke which, in my opinion is a lot more important than the right to bear arms. Stop being so damned co-operative. The more co-operative smokers are, the more bans get passed against them.
We keep hearing about America being the best country in the world because of its freedom and democracy, but Jerry Rubin doesn’t want people to have the freedom to smoke after a meal outside. Do we have to go to Russia to get that freedom? Anti-smokers’ idea of democracy consists of a self-righteous majority eternally persecuting a minority of which they disapprove. We mustn’t discriminate because of race, religion or sexuality, but it’s OK to discriminate based on a person’s chosen pleasures. He doesn’t like smoking, therefore, no one else may smoke. The obvious, obvious, obvious answer is to have smoking and non-smoking pubs and restaurants. Then customers and restaurateurs and workers alike have the freedom to choose where to go and everyone is happy. We heard so much about these poor restaurant workers who were going to die from side smoke — but go round the back of a restaurant and guess what you’ll probably see? A worker outside enjoying a cigarette while the poor customer inside, who would enjoy a cigarette after his dinner but can’t. But no, that’s not good enough for Mr. Rubin. He doesn’t want freedom of association. He doesn’t want the marketplace to decide. He wants a total ban.
How does this total ban mentality differ from the kind of thinking which lead to fascism? It’s not clear to me.
Democracy is about live and let live. It is not about a majority eternally forcing its will on the minority. How about some tolerance for people whose tastes and pleasures differ from yours, Jerry?
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 6, 2004. Read the original PDF.