IN YOUR SPACE
By Christina S. Porter
Interest rates are the lowest that they have been since 1958. This has brought an explosion in demand for commercial real estate, by both the investor and the user — demand also has been boosted by the high risks and low yields seen in alternative investments. The result is a sharp increase in commercial real estate prices and drop in capitalization rates.
For example, apartment prices in the Los Angeles Basin have nearly doubled in the past eight years, and apartment cap rates have fallen to below 6 percent in some cases. Similar, but less dramatic changes also have occurred in the retail, industrial and office markets. The key question is: What will happen to interest rates in the future? To answer this question, we’ve talked to some of the leading economists and mortgage lenders in the area. Their answer is unanimous — interest rates will be going up. However, most anticipate a relatively modest climb over the next 12 months, followed by a steeper climb starting in late 2004.
According to Mark Zandi, chief Economist at Economy.com, driving this increase in rates will be: ■Increased demand for capital by firms expanding in a strengthening economy. ■Reduced desire by the Fed to keep interest rates low. Once they see job growth occurring again and the GDP heating up (as projected for 2004), and once the presidential election takes place in the fall of 2004. ■Reduced demand for U.S. T-Bills and other U.S. securities by foreign investors, due to a projected drop in the value of the dollar. ■Moderate growth in inflation, particularly starting in 2005.
Specifically, Economy.com projects the Federal Funds Rate climbing slightly from its very low level of 1 percent today to 1.4 percent 12 months from now, and then more steeply to 5 percent by mid- 2006. Long-term mortgage rates are projected to climb from 5.5 percent today to 6.6 percent 12 months from now, and then to 7.4 percent by mid-2006.
The Blue Chip Economic Indicators group projects that the prime rate will bottom out at 4.05 percent in the fall 2003, then climb to 4.48 percent 12 months from now and to 4.84 percent by year-end 2004. (They do not provide projections for 2005).
John Gardener Sullivan, principal of Keystone Mortgage Corp., also expects interest rates to climb. He notes that while short-term interest rates remain low, long-term interest rates have already started to climb upward. For example, rates on 10-year T-Bills have moved from 3.1 percent in June to 4.1 percent in October. Rates on a typical $5 million commercial real estate loan are currently approximately 5.75 percent (10-year fixed, 25 year amortization schedule, 75 percent loan to lenders value). He sees the rates climbing by about 50 to 75 basis points over the next six months and by approximately 225 basis points over the next two to three years.
If interest rates were to climb by 225 basis points, mortgage payments would increase by about 23 percent. This likely would have a negative impact on property prices, although to what degree is difficult to quantify. Factors that would play in the equation include expected returns at the time from alternative investments, expected returns from real estate investments, the perceived risk associated with real estate, inflation, and the degree to which current property taxes have already been dampened to anticipated increases in mortgage rates.
The negative impact on prices that any increase in interest rates would have was cited by a number of NAI brokers as the reason that they have relatively conservative projections of future property values.
The above is taken from NAI Capital Commercial’s Market Report. (Christina S. Porter is a senior associate at NAI Capital Commercial Real Estate, where she specializes in leasing and selling office and industrial buildings.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 14, 2004. Read the original PDF.