Skip to content

REAL ESTATE Revisionist history: Surveys don’t tell the whole story

Published:

IS IT REALLY A JOBLESS

By Christina S. Porter

The Los Angeles Basin economy is clearly in an expansion mode at this time, and is projected to strengthen even more in the remainder of 2004 and in 2005. In the past 12 months, the Basin has seen: ■ $18.0 billion or 3.2% (constant $) growth in the region’s gross metropolitan product; ■ 138,000 or 1.6% growth in the number of employed residents; ■$3,091 or 3.2% growth in average household income; ■239,000 or 1.4% growth in population (including net in-migration to the region of 79,000 persons); ■$6.2 billion or 4.0% growth in retail sales; a slight drop in unemployment to 6.0%, ■3.1 million square feet (SF) or 1.2% growth in the pool of occupied office space, causing vacancy rates to drop to 16.7%; ■22.3 million square feet or 1.8% growth in the pool of occupied industrial space, causing vacancy rates to drop to 5.3%; ■0.7% growth in the pool of occupied retail space, causing vacancy rates to drop to 4.6%; ■0.7% growth in the number of occupied apartments, causing vacancy rates to drop to 3.6%.

These are generally healthy numbers. And even stronger growth rates are projected for the next 12 months: ■$21.3 billion or 3.8% (constant $) growth in the region’s gross metropolitan product; ■163,000 or 1.9% growth in the number of employed residents; ■$3,700 or 3.8% growth in average household income; ■260,000 or 1.6% growth in population; ■$8.1 billion or 5.0% growth in retail sales; ■Continued drop in unemployment to levels below 6.0%; ■Approximately 5 million square feet or 1.9% growth in the pool of occupied office space, causing vacancy rates to drop to approximately 15.7% (taking current level of construction into account); ■Approximately 25 million square feet or 2.0% growth in the pool of occupied industrial space, causing vacancy rates to drop to approximately 4.5%; ■Approximately 1% growth in the pool of occupied retail space, causing vacancy rates to drop to the low 4% range; and approximately 1% growth in the number of occupied apartments, causing vacancy rates to drop to the low 3% range.

Fueling these strong growth rates have been: ■A recovery in the nation’s economy (albeit not yet in employment); ■A strong competitive position by Southern California in terms of foreign trade, diversified manufacturing, entertainment, business services and engineering; ■Weaknesses in the economies and high costs of living and of conducting business in competing regions in Northern California and, to some extent, Seattle; ■Relatively low office rental rates; ■A general absence of disasters such as the earthquakes and riots that shook the area in the early and mid 1990s; ■A highly educated labor force and the concentration in the area of a number of cutting-edge firms; And the traditional pull factors of Southern California, including weather and lifestyle.

However, one significant threat to the area’s growth rate is high housing prices. Since 1995, housing prices in the Los Angeles Basin have increased 116%. During the same time period, prices nationwide increased by only 56%. We may soon be reaching the point where firms will find it difficult to recruit employees from outside the region. Note, however, that thus far, high housing prices have had only a minimal impact on economic growth in the Basin. Also, housing prices are even higher in the San Francisco Bay Area, and are no longer the bargain they once were in areas such as Seattle and Denver. Within the region, particularly strong growth is projected for Professional and Business Services (+48,300 jobs or 5.1%), as well as the other sectors — including financial activities and information — that tend to be housed in office space. This will drive strong growth in demand for office space.

RECOVERY? Data published by the California State Economic Development Department (EDD), from their survey of firms, indicates that wage and salary employment growth in the Los Angeles Basin and, indeed, all of California has been relatively anemic in the past 12 months. Specifically, they report that wage and salary employment in the Basin has grown by only 35,700 jobs, or 0.5%, from February 2003 to February 2004. This pales in comparison with growth rates in other economic indicators (for example, 3.2% growth in Gross Metropolitan Product), and with job growth witnessed in previous recovery years. However, EDD also publishes data from a survey of households that indicates that strong growth is taking place among employed residents in the Basin. This data shows that the number of employed residents has increased by 137,800 or 1.6% over the same time period. This data is more in-line with growth rates shown in other economic indicators and with job growth witnessed in previous recovery years. While the sample size of the household survey is smaller than the one conducted of firms, we believe that the household survey more accurately reflects actual job growth taking place within the Basin. In the early 1990s, the household survey turned out to be much more accurate than the firm survey, and major upward revisions were made to the firm surveys two and even three years after they were released. One of the major reasons for the revisions is that it was found that the survey of firms missed much of the job growth that was taking place in small and start-up businesses.

These firms were under-represented in the sample survey, and large, established firms (where job losses were still taking place) were over-represented. We believe that this is once again occurring. The survey of households is a more straight-forward survey, with a relatively stable contact list. In addition, the survey of households includes the self-employed in the job numbers, while the survey of firms does not. In our analysis, the most convincing evidence of strong job growth is the strong net absorption taking place in office and industrial space. Demand for office and industrial space generally lags job growth; firms tend to first expand their workforce and then to expand their space. Given the fact that NAI Capital Commercial and, indeed, all the major real estate brokerage houses, showed strong net absorption taking place throughout the Basin in 2003 strongly suggests that the job recovery is well underway, as shown by the household survey. (Christina S. Porter specializes in the leasing and selling of office and industrial buildings on the Westside of Los Angeles and beyond. You can contact her at)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 21, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe