By Christina S. Porter
Anyone who is involved in investment real estate today is aware of the challenge in finding an exchange property.
In 2002, the IRS issued a set of 15 guidelines under which investors looking for an exchange property can utilize the “Tenant in Common” ownership structure, which provides an additional avenue for deferring the payment of capital gains taxes when selling an investment property. Tenants in common is defined as a form of asset ownership in which two or more persons have an undivided interest in the asset, where the ownership shares are not required to be equal, and where ownership interests can be inherited.
There are many ways to become a tenant in common but there are two that I am most familiar. The first is by joining a group of investors who are interested in being tenants in common that are usually sponsored by a company with a good deal of experience in commercial real estate. This company/sponsor could also be known as a “Tenant In Common Investment Fund.” A sponsor arranges to purchase a property, raising the funds from investors and borrowing any additional capital necessary to complete the purchase. This company also will deal with the management transaction and of course, charging a fee for the service.
Some of the advantages of a TIC ownership interest are: ■ The ability of a small investor to become part owner of a much larger asset, many times of properties that only institutional buyers have access to. ■ Investment property owners whose properties have reached their full value or who are tired of managing their property can sell and diversify into different property types (become a tenant in common in more than one asset), collect the money and let someone else manage it. ■ Sponsors will generally be more “connected” than the small investor and very possibly have added sophistication in commercial real estate transactions with very detailed knowledge of the market place. ■ I am sure that all investment funds/sponsors operate differently but you might expect that they will develop a business plan for each property that will include an exit strategy. I think a few of the more significant advantages of this type of ownership in today’s market, are: 1. It is a less stressful way to find a suitable replacement property. 2. Dealing with people who are experts in this business (be sure to check all references carefully). 3. Not being personally involved in the day-to-day management and in most cases maintaining the same, if not increasing, your previous cash flow.
Attempting to purchase a property under the pressure of 1031 exchange required restrictions could put an investor at a tremendous disadvantage. Dealing with a TIC Investment fund/sponsor removes some of that pressure. They will most likely already have their eye on a property and have the ability to make a very clean deal, paying a much more reasonable price than a single investor might.
There are disadvantages to TIC ownership, most of which apply to single ownership as well. The one that stands out for me is the lack of liquidity. If you need to get your cash out you will have to find a buyer for your share of the property, or wait until it is sold. As of today there is no secondary market for TIC shares. As with any investment, you weigh your risks going in, and liquidity may or may not be an issue for you. One thing to note is that there is an ongoing debate as to whether a TIC is a real estate transaction or a securities transaction. Some say that it’s both. It’s a real estate transaction because it’s required that each investor owns title to a piece of real estate. It’s a securities transaction because TICs fall into the Securities and Exchange Commission regulations decree that revenue pooling like that of a TIC constitutes a securities offering. Be sure to look into this aspect of the deal carefully. (Christina S. Porter specializes in the leasing and selling of office and industrial buildings on the Westside of Los Angeles and beyond. You can contact her at)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 31, 2004. Read the original PDF.