Skip to content

Reasons why the Democrats deserve to lose the San Francisco mayor’s race

Published:

By Evelyn Jerome

Today is election day in San Francisco, and a win for Green Party candidate Matt Gonzalez could very well cement the city’s political insignificance on the national scene.

While former mayor Art Agnos, supporting Gonzalez, enjoys San Francisco’s image as “cantankerous” and “obstreperous,” the city will choose today between left and lefter, and between teetering on the edge of political normalcy and teetering off of it.

The east coast is laughing its snowed-in rear end off.

Gonzalez is running against Democratic county supervisor Gavin Newsom, a millionaire married to a model, hand-selected by outgoing mayor Willie Brown, who likes to get his way. Newsom is your run-of-the-mill Frisco Democrat: Pro-choice, pro-environment, pro-gay rights, pro-union, etc., and by the way, he’s easy on the eyes. How could he lose?

Well let’s see. Half of the city’s Democratic clubs have endorsed the Democratic supervisor, Newsom. And the other half have endorsed Gonzalez. Many of the city’s high-profile Democratic activists and elected officials have endorsed the Green. Greens from across the Western states are piling into San Francisco, sleeping on borrowed yoga mats and knocking on doors for Gonzalez.

Greens in San Francisco see the 40 years that Democrats have run the city the same way that the 1994 Republicans saw 40 years of Democratic rule in Washington and Congress. They hate it. And they smell their chance right now.

And the Democrats deserve it if they lose.

A year ago California Democrats were on top of the world, having won all eight statewide constitutional offices and having swept the legislative races to hold tight control of both houses of the state legislature. Democrats were in charge.

Just 11 months later, Democrats were caught in the highbeams of a Hummer, and now we’re hanging our heads in shame, as the state’s voters handed us Gray Davis’ head on a plate.

Democrats have an organizational problem. October’s election gave us the first glimpse of it, and today’s may be the second. Just like they tell you in the 12-step programs — you’ve got to recognize that you have a problem before you can fix it.

We Democrats actually seem to have a two-sided problem — we’re losing folks from each end of our far-reaching spectrum. The recall election showed us that we’re losing moderate Democrats who are looking for action and results with fiscal efficiency. And frankly, a multi-billion dollar deficit with Democrats controlling both houses of the legislature and the top spot didn’t help.

And as the 2000 election proved to us, we’re losing liberal voters from the left to the Green Party, and today’s San Francisco contest may give the Greens the boost they’ve needed to prevent Democrats from telling voters that a vote for the Green candidate is a waste.

So we’re shrinking, we recently invincible California Democrats. And if we shrink enough, we will find that the national candidates will quickly go from taking us for granted to writing us off as a loss.

Given that we are 11 months away from the next presidential election, now would be a great time for California Democrats to regroup, reorganize, and redouble our efforts to give as many voters as possible something they can grasp within the Democratic Party.

And by the way, it’s not so big a deal if Matt Gonzalez wins Frisco today. Santa Monica, until recently, had a Green mayor.

Evelyn Jerome is a communications consultant, a past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 9, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe