Skip to content

Recall of Gov. Davis a waste of money or an insult to democratic process?

Published:

By Evelyn Jerome

Let me say right off the bat, for those who might think otherwise, that I’ll vote “no” on the recall of Gov. Gray Davis, if it ever qualifies for the ballot.

But I’m not appalled or aghast that California’s right-wing Republicans, embittered by losing last November in a close-when-it-wasn’t-supposed-to-be election, are now trying another avenue.

I don’t think this recall effort is a massive abuse of our democracy. In fact, the recall effort is a legitimate use of the democratic process. There’s a difference between recall and impeachment — we impeach governors and presidents for “high crimes and misdemeanors,” but a recall can be requested for almost any reason, if enough people sign the petitions.

I went right to the source to determine if this recall effort is really an abuse of the system. Here’s what our state constitution says about recalling an elected official: “Recall is the power of the electors to remove an elective officer.” And later: “Sufficiency of reason is not reviewable,” which means that you have to give a reason for asking to recall an elected official, but no one has the power to say, “That’s not a legitimate enough reason.”

Is it a massive waste of time and privately-raised political dollars? Yes. Will it waste the ridiculous sum of $30 million of your tax dollars that we can’t afford if it passes? Yes.

Is it an abuse of the process? I don’t think so.

Politics has become a contact sport in the past decade or so, with the cheerleaders more like jeerleaders. Think about how those smirks at Jimmy Carter in the ‘70s became vitriolic hatred towards the Clintons in the ‘90s. Think of the generation that Rush Limbaugh told it’s OK to call the President a liar and a traitor.

And unfortunately, the right wing does not have a corner on political venom. Think of how many times you’ve read my column and cursed me, calling me stupid or a Neanderthal.

True conservatives would have accepted the loss and waited four years, not putting our nearly bankrupt state through the possible $30 million expenditure of running an election. I don’t think the recall effort has the support of true conservatives who know this. It’s supported instead by a vindictive bunch of sore losers.

But no matter how much you disagree, the democratic process gives them the right to petition a recall. Let them gather signatures while we solve the bigger problem: California’s mammoth budget deficit. A balanced budget will speak louder than a bullhorn. (Evelyn Jerome is the founder and principal of Strategic Communications, a communications consulting firm. She is the past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 1, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe