Skip to content

Reclaiming labor policy from the extremists

Published:

On Sept. 18, this paper published a front page article on the campaign by workers at the Four Points Sheraton to win representation with the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union (HERE). The article provides several quotes from antiunion workers — including one comparing union officials to “roaches” — but none from pro-union workers, even though a majority of the workers have signed cards requesting HERE representation. The article also describes the National Right to Work Foundation (NRTWF) as a “non-profit that gives free legal aid to workers who claim they've been strong-armed into unionizing” — language taken almost word-for-word from the organization’s Web site. It fails to mention that the NRTWF is an extreme right-wing organization dedicated to destroying the fundamental freedom to form a union. The NRTWF has no interest in the workers at the Four Points Sheraton other than to use them to advance its “nationwide” campaign against workers who seek to form unions. In support of this national campaign, it receives millions of dollars from far-right foundations and organizations such as the Olin Foundation, the Evergreen Freedom Foundation and Castle Rock.

The article alleges that union organizers have adopted heavy-handed tactics and invaded the privacy of employees by visiting them at home. It fails to mention that, under U.S. law, unions are denied access to employees at the workplace and that employers relentlessly invade employees’ privacy and intimidate them through mandatory anti-union meetings at the workplace (a form of false imprisonment), antiunion literature predicting job loses in the event of a union victory, and one-on-one meetings between workers and supervisors, who can be sacked for refusing to participate in the anti-union campaign.

Aggressive and illegal anti-union campaigns are a pervasive and routine aspect of workplace relations in America. The right to form a union now exists only on paper. In practice, employers are able to exercise virtual veto power over that “right.” But don’t take my word for it: Human Rights Watch, one of the world’s most respected human rights organizations, recently delineated the full extent of employer and consultant coercion in the United States. It concluded that “many workers... are spied on, harassed, pressured, threatened, suspended, fired, deported or otherwise victimized in reprisal for their exercise of the right” to choose a union.

The Human Rights Watch report indicates the real reason why workers seeking to form unions have increasingly turned to the process of card certification — (where the employer recognizes the union on the basis of membership cards signed by a majority of employees) — their desire to circumvent employers’ lengthy, aggressive and frequently illegal anti-union campaigns. The NRTWF opposes card certification because it realizes that, unlike National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) elections, card certification provides little opportunity for employers to intimidate workers. As the NRTWF well understands, workers seeking to form unions have nothing to fear from free and fair elections. According to research by Harvard economist Richard Freeman, there are now over 40 million workers in the United States who would like union representation but are unlikely to get it under the current system. The problem with NLRB elections is that, as a result of employer coercion, they are neither free nor fair: They are elections without democracy.

The reasons that these 40 million workers want to form unions are clear. Recent research by the Economic Policy Institute has demonstrated that unions raise wages and health benefits by about 28 percent, that unionized workers receive better pension plans than their non-union counterparts, and that unionized workers receive 26 percent more vacation time. Just last week HERE negotiated raises of 44 percent over eight years and pension increases of 80 percent for almost 3,000 low paid clerical workers at Yale University.

Extremists committed to eviscerating workers’ rights have hijacked labor policy in this country. This is why millions of Americans lack decent health benefits and pensions while failing CEOs continue to plunder the nation’s wealth. And this is why 40 million Americans who want to form a union are unable to do so. It is time to put extremists like the NRTWF out of business and reassert the fundamental right to form a union.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 29, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe