By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
Over the last eight years, I have owned and managed partnerships that purchased and operated apartment buildings. So it may surprise you that I do not support a recent lawsuit brought by a group of Santa Monica landlords seeking to abolish rent control.
As a landlord, I have tried to act ethically. I had a simple philosophy: If tenants paid their rent on time, maintained their unit without undo damage and didn’t disturb other tenants, they deserved a clean building, timely maintenance, privacy and to have legitimate concerns addressed in a timely manner, regardless of the amount of the rent they paid.
Having said that, as a manager of a real estate partnership it was my fiduciary duty to maximize profit, which means increasing rents as expeditiously as possible. In fact, to not do so would be as unethical as a stockbroker buying his clients stocks in failing companies because he felt sorry for the CEOs.
The landlords’ suit claims that Santa Monica’s rent control law is unconstitutional because it protects the rich as well as the poor. And while this reasoning has some validity — even Community Corporation, a non-profit that provides affordable housing in Santa Monica, has provisions to move tenants who start to earn more into more expensive programs — the landlords’ solution is too Draconian.
I have been a renter. I know what it feels like to fear every rent increase; worried that a shift in market conditions might force me from my home and into a diminished lifestyle. Even when I started doing better financially, it would have been impossible to plan my financial future without predictable housing costs. For you homeowners, it would be the equivalent of your bank having the right to increase your mortgage payment by 20 percent because they could.
Which is why I believe in rent control. What I don’t believe in is the way Santa Monica (and West Hollywood) conceive of and administer their programs.
The rent regulations originally enacted by Santa Monica in 1978 — pushed in by Santa Monica’s ruling party: Santa Monicans for Renters Rights (S.M.M.R.) — was shamefully unfair. The lack of vacancy control — now court-mandated — squeezed landlords so badly that they were forced to defer all but emergency maintenance. I remember visiting friends in buildings that had become so dilapidated they seemed like slums. And more than a few mom-and-pop landlords watched helplessly as their entire life savings were wiped out by this egregious law.
Even now, the annual rent increases, intended to accurately reflect inflation and operational increases, are exceptionally stingy. This year’s increase was a miserly 1.3 percent capped at $20, compared to 3 percent for buildings right over the border in Los Angeles. Even parsimonious West Hollywood permitted a 2.7-percent increase.
And trying to evict a bad tenant in Santa Monica or West Hollywood, even if they are destructive, disruptive or dangerous, is near impossible.
For instance, one of my tenants began hammering on the walls, smashing furniture and having loud arguments — even though he lived alone and didn’t have guests — at 3 a.m. each day. When tenants or staff complained, he became abusive and threatening. The man’s mother admitted that her son had been institutionalized and was probably off his meds. Needless to say, he threatened to file a false complaint with the city.
When I called West Hollywood rent control for help, their first response was to imply that we were at fault. When I explained that the mother had warned us that her son had a history of mental disorders, violence and that he represented a danger to the other tenants, and that all I wanted to know was if there was a way to expedite his eviction before he killed someone, the case officer suggested that we all get together for a little chat and work it all out. I had a suggestion of my own, but my editor will not allow me to print it.
The problem with such a “guilty until proved innocent” prejudice against landlords is that savvy tenants use it to game the cities. It is not uncommon for a tenant, aware that they are about to be evicted, to intentionally damage their unit and file a false complaint claming lack of maintenance. And these pro-tenant cities are all too willing to be their accomplice, delaying evictions and demanding repairs that were subsequently undone when the tenant was ultimately evicted.
Such policies chase away many of the ethical landlords who find the city’s unreasonable bias too trying to manage. I, myself, have passed up more than one building simply because it was located in Santa Monica or West Hollywood.
In addition, this discrimination creates an adversarial relationship between landlords and the city. And while the city, led by its S.M.R.R. contingent, does not seem particularly concerned, they might well be.
While it is true that the current lawsuit is likely to, and should, fail, this will probably not always be the case. With President Bush stacking the federal courts with anti-regulation judges, it is only a matter of time before rent control is struck down. When that happens, the last thing that Santa Monica — or renters — will need is an angry mob of landlords intent on revenge. (Comments or requests for copies of this column can be e-mailed to)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 26, 2005. Read the original PDF.