Skip to content

Reliable identity cards protect liberty, security

Published:

COMMON SCENTS

By CAROLE ORLIN

I don’t believe that anyone can argue with the notion that 9/11 permanently changed the way we view our world, vote for our political leaders, prioritize how our tax dollars are spent or make our air travel plans. Although I miss the pre-9/11 innocence, however deluded that was, I find that I am learning to live in this new world. Maybe it’s just adaptation. Maybe it’s the fact that there is no turning back. We can’t un-ring the bell. 9/11 did happen.

Really, there are only two choices. Grab the bull by the horns, accept reality and learn how to be successful in navigating this new world, or live in the past. The fact remains that we need to find new and better ways to be safer in our country now. I am convinced that we have sworn enemies that will never rest until they have annihilated us, no matter what we do. For me, part of navigating this new world is being more aware of what is happening around me, and what is happening in my government. It means getting more involved than I ever thought I would, and not taking any part of my life for granted.

When something new is proposed in the name of “homeland security,” I find that I need to take particular care in checking it out thoroughly to make certain that some other agenda is not being carried out in the name of security. That very word is said often enough to get legislation enacted. What are we willing to accept to feel more secure? Who actually read or analyzed the USA Patriot Act, which Congress passed with virtually no debate only 45 days after the Sept. 11 attacks? Numerous questions have subsequently surfaced about the potential for abuse by the FBI under Section 215 of the Act. Section 215 gives broad powers to order any person or entity to turn over “any tangible things” so long as the FBI specifies the order is “for an authorized investigation … to protect against international terrorism or clandestine intelligence activities.” The FBI need not show probable cause, nor reasonable grounds to believe that the person whose records it seeks is engaged in criminal activity. There is a real potential for violations of a number of individual rights under the First, Fourth and Fifth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution.

With that said, let’s not be ignorant of the fact that some extraordinary changes in our societal obsession with “political correctness” might have to be accepted. For example, the notion of profiling air-line passengers does occur, and can be a useful tool if proper safeguards are put into place. Where I can see some legitimate debate about the balancing of “rights” arising from the Patriot Act, I cannot see any legitimate controversy arising over the recent legislation that passed — by a vote of 261-161 — the U.S. House of Representatives earlier this month. This measure is called the Real ID Act (H.R. 418), and includes a series of rules that are aimed at forcing states to issue all adults federally approved electronic ID cards, including driver’s licenses.

This legislation appears to be a direct response to the findings and recommendations of the National Commission on Terrorists Attacks Upon the United States, and its final report of 2004. All but one of the 9/11 hijackers acquired some form of U.S. identification documents to rent cars and apartments, buy airline tickets, pass through security checkpoints and board planes. You know the rest. The 9/11 Commission’s Report pointed to identity cards and driver’s licenses as central to efforts in ensuring that they are made more secure. Most Americans use their driver’s licenses as their main form of identification. Passports are used less frequently. Under the rules of the House of Representatives bill, federal employees would be able to reject licenses or identity cards that do not comply with the measure, thereby restricting access to airplanes, trains, federal courthouses, national parks and other areas that are under federal jurisdiction. The legislation requires that driver’s licenses and other ID cards include a digital photograph and anti-counterfeiting features. Some states already require this, others do not. Before being issued this document, the applicant would have to present a picture identity document, proof of date of birth and social security number, and documentation showing the address of his or her principal residence. The state would be required to verify the validity of these documents. Applicants would also be required to prove U. S. citizenship or lawful presence in the United States. For those temporarily in the United States, the date of expiration of the identity card would have to match the date that lawful presence in the country also expired. Three years from the date of the passage of this statute the federal government would no longer accept any other form of state identification for purposes of federal identification.

This new identity security legislation would not substantially change the types of uses or the frequency of use of driver’s licenses for identification. The most significant change relates to increasing the reliability of driver’s licenses, which most Americans prefer to use for ID purposes. One thing we know for sure is that for terrorists, an identity document is a way to gain access to sensitive areas. A secure system of identification will make it more difficult for a terrorist or anyone to obtain an identity document by fraud. This legislation, which has been sent to the U.S. Senate for action — and received strong support from the Bush Administration — finds itself under attack from the political left (the ACLU likened the new rules to a “de facto national ID card”) and from the political right (the Gun Owners of America called the bill a “bureaucratic back door to implementation of a national ID card”).

How about keeping focused on the matter at hand? In the world we live in today, reliable identity documents are critical both for promoting security and for protecting liberties. (Carole)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 28, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe