Skip to content

Religion taken to the extreme

Published:

By Peter Altschuler Santa Monica

Perhaps the best response to Mr. Nichols’ faith-based assertions (SMDP, Aug. 8, page 5) are on page one of the SMDP’s Aug. 8 edition. If there needs to be evidence of Christian extremism, it’s the protesters from the Cornerstone Ministries at the Hare Krishna Festival.

The notion that Christianity is the only true faith, that Christ is the only true savior, and that the billions of other worshippers on the planet are damned is prejudicial, prideful and unprovable. When Christianity was still developing as a faith in the first two centuries after the death of Jesus, Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, and Judaism had been around for centuries. The preachings of Jesus, if they’re accurate at all outside of Paul’s letters, made their way into the various gospels anywhere from dozens of years to generations after his death. How interpretive did they become in support of various sectarian divisions within the faith, even at that early stage? And how much did they draw on Greek writings from the same era, as some scholars of scripture have shown?

The fact is that every major religion shares the same core precepts found in Christianity, and they breed the same extremists. Atrocities have been committed in the name of every faith, and Christianity is not exempted. Consider the Spanish Inquisition, the Salem witch trials, sexual abuses by priests or the homophobic rantings of televangelists who otherwise profess to “love thy neighbor as thyself”... as long as he’s the right kind of Christian, of course.

“If English was good enough for Jesus Christ, it’s good enough for me.” — a member of Congress declared, during a debate on teaching foreign languages in American high schools

As Blaise Pascal, the French mathematician, observed, “Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction.” It was an observation made, by the way, in the mid-1600s.

I can think of at least 100 different ways to get from my house in Santa Monica to my wife’s office in West LA. I can also imagine that, if there were only one route, many people who left at 8 a.m. might never arrive before it was time to go home. The routes to reach God are, more than likely, just as numerous because, like those 100 ways to reach West LA, some work better for some people than they do for others. Yet fundamentalist Christians, Muslim extremists, Hindu radicals and Jewish right-wingers all insist that there’s only one way — their way — and you’re either with them or against them.

If Mr. Nichols took his own advice — as stated on his Web site home page — to provide “creative and committed work toward the best possible outcome,” he’d worry less about attacks on his faith and, instead, work against those whose actions provoke such attacks. He’d help people find their own best way to God... even if it were not his... just as Gandhi (in the film version, at least) told a Hindu who had killed a Muslim child to adopt a Muslim orphan and raise him... as a Muslim.

The more that Christians insist on having everyone else do what the Christians tell them to do, the more extreme the responses against those Christians will be, especially here in America. Tolerance is a cornerstone of our society, not an option you can decide should be restricted when your own point of view is not accepted. Yet I’ve been to two fundamentalist sermons where the minister proclaimed that civil law in the United States had outlived its usefulness and now was the time to replace it with Biblical law. That’s not just a point of view. That’s anarchy.

If the world is too much with us, join a sect like the Amish. Retreat into a community of like-minded souls. Just don’t insist, in this country at least, that it’s OK for you to claim the supremacy of your beliefs without allowing someone else the freedom to make the same claim. Do, however, remember that this is the country in which

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 12, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe