Skip to content

Religion: The good, the bad and the ugly

Published:

By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN

It seems that if I breathe the word “Christian” in a column, the religious “write” launches a blitzkrieg of hate mail. The nicer ones accuse me of being anti- Christian, anti-Religious or bigoted. And some, well, lets just say their language is quite un-Christian.

When religious reactionaries label someone a bigot or anti-Christian, their intent is often to avoid scrutiny or the need to defend corrupt and abusive practices. This is accomplished through: character assassination, thus invalidating the criticism, and intimidation designed to deter future criticism. Such blanket accusations are neither honest nor accurate.

Though I have serious concerns with certain practices of organized religions and cults, this does not in any way make me either anti-Christian or anti-religious. Further, I am appreciative of the great good that can come from spiritual and religious beliefs. However, there are aspects of religion that can be quite bad, and, at its worst, downright ugly.

THE GOOD Religious beliefs can provide comfort during times of hardship and suffering, such as coping with the death of a loved one or during a prolonged illness. Faith has helped some to find the strength to conquer addictions or change harmful behavior. And when confronted by the uncertainties of our mortality, faith can provide answers and assurances.

Honesty and integrity — increasingly rare these days — are frequently a reflection of religious principles. And many religions offer the means for a believer to put past mistakes behind them and begin life anew.

Churches, temples, mosques and other spiritual institutions provide community, friendship, social activities and support. These same organizations are capable of doing great works of charity. And it is those groups that are willing to go to the most undesirable places and help those all others have forsaken.

THE BAD For each of the above attributes, there are negatives. Religious groups can provide comfort, but it can also be the source of suffering. Women have been routinely forced to remain in emotionally or physically abusive marriages. Many of those women and their children have endured severe and repeated beatings, or even been killed because of intractable religious doctrine.

The belief in an afterlife may reassure us, but it also cheapens our mortal life. This has made the religious extreme among the most heartless when it comes to certain types of misery. Those at the end of their life can be subjected to unimaginable agony because the religious extreme insist on keeping them alive, regardless of their wishes or beliefs.

And while these same people will use all extraordinary medical means to keep someone alive, they will use speculative biblical interpretation to block new and potentially revolutionary research that could end disease and misery for millions.

But even those objections are hypocritically selective. Christian and other groups have attempted to block stem cell research because of the destruction of a pinhead-sized blastocyst, yet the destruction of those very same pre-embryos in the course of fertility procedures is met with silence.

And while religious organizations have provided care for the millions of poor and sick, the strings attached can result in even greater harm. In Africa, for example, the Catholic Church was instrumental in reducing the infant mortality rate from nine deaths out of every 10 to 1 out of 10. But their prohibition of birth control resulted in a population explosion that caused millions to die of starvation.

In addition, the explosion of AIDS can be partly attributed to the refusal of religious groups to promote condom use. And for George Bush, an American president, to insert his narrow religious views by denying financial aid to any health organization that promotes the use of condoms to prevent AIDS, is unconstitutional, immoral and unforgivable.

Another noble aspect of religion is the idea of absolution or repentance. But, while the Catholic confessional is, in theory, only for the truly penitent, in practice it is often used as absolution for serial philandering, violence, greed and other antisocial behavior. And though being “born again” can provide a well-deserved second chance, too often it is an excuse to dismiss bad or immoral behavior without any contrition or consequences.

President Bush is a perfect example. He was guilty of drug and alcohol abuse, casual sex, insider trading and questionable land deals. Yet, rather than admit to his transgressions, make restitutions, or share a cell with Martha Stewart, he simply became “born again.” Coincidentally this coincided with his pursuit of political office. And being born again does not seem to preclude the president from engaging in further lying, cheating, stealing or torture.

THE UGLY Religious distortions have combined with ignorance in the justification of the most heinous of human crimes. Burning thousands of witches at the stake is case in point. Little has changed today, though the current religious witch-hunts entail persecuting gays.

Corrupted religious leaders have been among the worst promoters of racism. Look under the hood of almost any Klansman and you’ll find a devout church member. But then again, it’s not a big leap from “my religion is superior” to “my race is superior.”

In addition, most religious groups have given a green light to the subjugation of women. The result is that through much of modern history, 50 percent of the population has been systematically subjected to abuse, indentured servitude and even murder.

Religious chauvinism also translates into religious intolerance. It is this arrogance in particular that has been the source of murder, torture, terrorism, genocide and countless wars.

Good and bad in religion may be matters of opinion, but when religion turns ugly, it is indisputably evil. And anyone who defends such corruption and immorality by attacking those who condemn it, are ugly as well. (Ed Silverstein)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 20, 2006. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe