By Michael J. Tittinger
Tensions continue to mount in Iraq amid the power vacuum left behind by the recent conflict involving the United States and the deposed regime of Saddam Hussein. A nation stands in limbo, on the precipice of its biggest reformation in decades, maybe centuries.
The United States is not only grappling with patrolling and safeguarding a nation — a nation growing increasingly restless as it awaits its fate — but also is combating influences from both within Iraq and outside its borders that would see the newly instilled government linked to its constituents’ religious tendencies.
U.S. officials have openly worried, with good reason, that the majority Shi’ites might attempt to forge an Islamic republic akin to the one governing the nation’s longtime rival — Iran. Thankfully, the United States has remained steadfast on two conditions for the new national governance of Iraq — the government will be a democracy and there will exist a separation of church and state.
In the long run, the Iraqis will likely be grateful for such a separation.
For an interlocked church and state is an ideal … as long as humanity stays out of it. And since humanity has to be involved, since it is for humanity, it’s a paradox. Not knowing if your neighbors share the exact same beliefs and live by the exact same moral doctrine that we do, a religion-tied government is the absolute worst strategy, even for those wishing to hold true to the most extremist of tenants.
History has shown time and again the inherent problems that arise in such a state whereby no true separation exists. So now we have a true separation of the two codes of law in most nations — the only possible successful alternative solution because it does indeed involve humanity.
Forgive me as I wax theology on y’all. The only way that the church and state union could possibly work is if we all had the same spiritual needs and views, which we obviously do not, and if no one contained within them the terribly human tendency to go to extremes or lust for power. Two pretty big “ifs.”
This need for separation of which I speak does allow for differences and extremes, which, consequently, also allows for such variations that the people in church-state unionized countries think are our ticket to hell. But in the end, it makes for an environment more suited for us to rightly claim our divine nature, or true happiness.
If a wealthy man is asked to donate to an established UCLA scholarship fund, he may feel good that he was able to help a would-be student achieve his life-long dream. But if a working-class man toils tirelessly to help someone achieve his or her life-long dream, he would feel a sense of fulfillment you can’t put a price tag on. Even though the poorer man would be all the more poor, in monetary terms, he would have a greater understanding of things like love, community and sacrifice — the very elements that the church-state union regimes hope to synthetically instill in people.
Cognizant that no man is an island, we know that if we give or sacrifice on our volition it is much more rewarding than if we are forced to do so. So we are left with this imperfect system that permits all those evils of the world to creep in. It allows its people to worship Satan, the sun or the almighty dollar if they wish, but it also gives us each the chance to be good little boys and girls on our own. This is in stark contrast to those people in the world who are told to be good, and stick to the straight and narrow mostly out of fear for repercussions.
The moral of the story is that a separation of church and state unwittingly allows us an even greater opportunity to achieve a divine nature (the goal of church) than the union of church and state, for we must choose to do so on our own … free will.
Thankfully, upon closer scrutiny, the new Iraq seems less and less suitable to a government that would not make that distinct separation. The leading Iraqi ayatol-lah, Ali al-Sestani, believes that a separation of church and state is in the nation’s best interests, and unlike Iran, there exists a substantial secular middle class in Iraq.
Iran’s Foreign Minister Kamal Kharrazi admitted as much last week, noting that Iraq’s religious and ethnic diversity made it unsuitable for a true Islamic state, an unsuitability the Iraqis will no doubt be thankful for down the road. (Mike Tittinger is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. To reach him, e-mail to).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 1, 2003. Read the original PDF.