Skip to content

Restaurants in the zone could face tough choices

Published:

By Tom Larmore

Guest Opinion by Tom Larmore

(Editor’s note: This is the second installment in a series of columns about the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded, which is before voters this November.)

In last week’s column, I stated that one of the reasons I believe the Santa Monica’s minimum wage ordinance constitutes bad policy is that it will lead to a loss of jobs and job opportunities for unskilled workers. The best example of this phenomenon will be in restaurants.

The typical restaurant expends approximately 30 percent of its sales for labor. Many of these employees are paid at or near minimum wage (currently $6.75 an hour) because most of their income is derived from tips.

A waiter or waitress in a successful Ocean Avenue restaurant, for example, may make $25 per hour or more from tips alone. Tips are shared with certain other employees, such as bussers, although there are some who do not receive tip income. These are usually the entry-level jobs, such as dishwashers.

The City of Santa Monica’s law provides no credit for tips received by restaurant employees. This means that waiters making over $30 per hour will be required to be paid an additional $4-$5.50 per hour by the employer.

The bottom line is that labor costs will increase by at least 50-60 percent. Simple arithmetic tells us that an increase in costs of 15-20 percent of sales will swamp the normal restaurant profit margin of 5-7 percent of sales.

Since cost increases of this magnitude cannot possibly be absorbed, restaurants will probably try the following options, none of which are acceptable:

Restaurants are in a very competitive and uncertain business, particularly in Santa Monica. Those covered by the ordinance (by being located in the designated zone and grossing over $5 million in annual sales) compete with others that are either located outside the zone but nearby or are slightly smaller.

Attempting to increase prices by 15-20 percent across the board would create a major competitive problem for any restaurant, thereby making this option unfeasible. Would you and your friends continue to patronize a restaurant if its prices increased this much?

2. Reduce labor costs. Restaurants will certainly analyze ways in which they can cut back on labor. One method would be to simply reduce the number of employees, while seeking to increase productivity by increasing workloads. Employees with more experience may be available because of the required increase in pay. The downside, of course, is the elimination of job opportunities for entry-level workers. (This was the point of my apple story last week.)

30E,3. Reduce other costs. The major expenses for restaurants other than labor are food, equipment (including appliances, silverware, linens and similar items needed to operate the business, and interest on loans) and rent. There is very little a restaurant can do to significantly reduce these costs, particularly in an environment where rent has been steadily increasing.

4. Reduce revenue to get below the $5 million threshold. This is a strategy some restaurants have already considered. A restaurant can simply close during the more unprofitable hours — lunch for example — in order to reduce sales while maintaining an acceptable profit margin. Of course, workers who retain their jobs will not be helped and those who are suddenly superfluous will be looking for jobs elsewhere.

501,5. Seek a hardship exemption. The ordinance includes a provision allowing the city to give annual hardship exemptions to businesses that cannot comply with the mandated wage scale and remain viable. For the reasons set forth above, restaurants would almost certainly qualify. While there are several problems with the exemption concept, the primary difficulty is that the annual nature of the exemption makes it impossible to sign leases, obtain loans or make other long-term commitments.

6. Close. Restaurants, particularly along the Third Street Promenade, are already being hit with cost increases from worker’s compensation premiums, rent and other sources. If they are unable to avoid paying the 80 percent increase in the minimum wage mandated by the ordinance, they will ultimately have no choice.

Proponents of the ordinance incorrectly argue that the impact on restaurants will be minimal because only a few have annual revenues of $5 million.

Next week, I’ll address this point and have some further thoughts about restaurants based on a recent article in the Los Angeles Business Journal, which reported that several restaurants are unwilling to locate in Santa Monica because of this ordinance.

(Tom Larmore is a property rights attorney and a Santa Monica resident.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 11, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe