By (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is an education policy consultant and a visiting scholar at UCLA’s Institute for social science research. She)
“Let thy love in kisses rain,” Percy Shelley exclaims, and I swoon. There is nothing I adore more than gallant gestures, bold pronouncements, and the sense of urgency that accompanies passion. I believe in love with all my heart. It is the most profound expression of caring that exists in this world.
As a romantic, I am overjoyed that my gay and lesbian friends who live in Massachusetts are now able to legally marry. But none of these emotions should obscure the real issue about why it is that gay marriage should be legal across the country.
States don’t care about love. States care about property.
John Locke explains: “The reason why men enter into society is the preservation of their property; and the end, while they choose and authorize a legislature is that there may be laws made and rules set, as guards and fences to properties of all the society.”
Marriage is important to the state because it helps order society and secure property. It promotes monogamy, stability, the financial commingling of assets, and often times, progeny. Order, security and property provide the state an opportunity to further the peace and prosperity of its citizens. From the state’s perspective, change leads to chaos, which is why divorce is bad and out of wedlock unions are worse.
In the Western world, marriage (and ironically, divorce beginning with Henry VIII) grew out of a desire to join property, not hearts.
It wasn’t until the late Middle Ages — after the advent of courtly love and chivalry — that individuals sought to combine notions of romantic love and the institution of marriage. For nearly the first 1,000 years of Christianity, to love your spouse romantically was akin to adultery. Love was reserved for God alone. During this time, most marriages were arranged, women came with dowries — bringing property to the marriage — and love, if it occurred at all, came with intrigue, shame, and sin. Only pagans (read: Romans and other Celtic “savages”) celebrated love openly.
It took several hundred years, until the Victorian era, before society fully embraced the idea of love with marriage. But by that time, the church was, if not separate, certainly a distinct institution from the state. Freedom of religion had been codified in the founding documents of the United States; and several religions defined marriage differently from the state: Some allowed for polygamy, some for divorce, some for neither.
Quite notably, many states have been indifferent on the subject of who you love (for example, in many parts of this country inter-racial marriages have been permitted for some time), as long as there was no harm involved (two consenting adults, no incest, no bigamy), or potential problems with the match (blood type or other health concerns).
Historically, there was a greater resistance to love being a part of marriage than there was to who should be married.
Here’s The Thing: A member of Congress once said: “Don’t let the facts cloud the issue.” This is where we seem to be in this debate because no rational or historical argument can be made on the side of: “marriage is a sacred institution,” when it is so clearly about property and order from the state’s perspective. Sadly, today’s debate seems to be about prejudice, not love.
People who are against the state allowing for same-sex marriages are either misinformed about the institution of marriage, or misguided in allowing their personal, private and/or religious beliefs to influence their opinions. We would all be much better off — a more orderly, secure society — if same-sex marriages were legal across the nation.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 20, 2004. Read the original PDF.