Skip to content

Road rage: SUV backlash masks greater problem

Published:

By Michael J. Tittinger

A pair of new television ads aimed at curbing Americans’reliance on foreign oil fires upon a familiar foe — the venerable sports utility vehicle.

Once portrayed as the ultimate motor vehicle for the red-blooded American, enticing owners with images of independence, attitude and free will, the SUV and its place in the American lexicon has done a complete turnabout. The 4-by-4s are currently the bane of liberal existence, representing all that is evil in this world due to their larger gas tanks and their compromised fuel efficiency.

A pair of 30-second spots produced for the Detroit Project, a nonprofit organization started by syndicated columnist Arianna Huffington, began airing in six U.S. cities this week, including Los Angeles. Especially Los Angeles!

Of course, California is also where gas-guzzling muscle cars come to die and are continually given stays of execution.

The ads were created in part by the team that brought us the universally recognized “Got Milk?” campaign. They mimic existent anti-drug commercials that connect recreational drug use here with crimes against humanity in South America. The new spots make inference to the growing opinion that gas-guzzling SUVs are empowering the very terrorists we’re flying across the world to destroy.

Television stations in New York and Detroit, as well as both KABC and KCBS in Los Angeles, have rejected the new ads.

“This campaign is not designed to demonize SUV owners,” says Huffington. “We want to encourage customers to connect the dots.”

Kind of like how PETA asks fur coat consumers to connect the dots when they splatter red paint all over their sheared beaver bomber coats. Opponents of the ads are critical of the Detroit Project’s approach, likening it to an unregulated guilt trip. A spokesman for the Competitive Enterprise Institute dismissed the spots as “elitist nonsense.”

Where the ads appear to fall short is in their lack of ingenuity or problem solving. The commercials are imaginative in that they attract attention with their use of comic irony, depicting SUV owners, in one instance, as equally proud of their vehicle’s features as they are contributing to a nightclub’s bombing overseas.

The commercials are intended to be tongue in cheek, and their use of the embattled SUV is to be taken as an example of how we all could stand to be more fuel conscious. Point taken. Let’s move on. Most people who have researched and purchased an SUV are either well aware of the sacrificed fuel efficiency and decide to pull the trigger anyway, or don’t believe their passing on buying one will make much difference.

Still, the message is out that SUVs waste more fuel than most cars.

One problem with the ads is that they pick on the conventional target and, in effect, do “demonize” the SUV owner because it polarizes the commuters — placing guilt on the SUV owners and letting all others temporarily off the hook. We all need to “make socially responsible choices,” claims Huffington.

At this point, railing against the SUV — the target du jour — is about as effective and imaginative as blasting the cigarette smokers for fouling up the air. Few smokers can excuse their habit today as a practice they took up “before we knew it was bad for you.” They are cognizant that it kills and yet they lay down their money and their lungs regardless. They’ve weighed their options and continued to smoke. Guilt trips won’t likely prompt them to butt out. SUV owners know the tale of the tape as well when they take out a second mortgage for a car as big as a second house.

A second problem with the ads is that they offer us no solutions, no suggestions, no guidelines in which to follow towards the light of sensible oil use aside from, of course, selling the SUV. There are plenty of ways to squander fossil fuels — heating unoccupied houses, splashing around in motor boats, shrugging off public transportation — that a hackneyed attack on the usual suspect, the SUV, is getting old.

There’s little doubt the Detroit Project’s heart is in the right place. Attacking Americans’ tendency to overconsume natural fuels is in the best interest of the country. And putting their faith in others to willingly surrender their beloved SUVs is noble, but it’s unlikely to have any real impact aside from a backlash towards the drivers of such vehicles. The goal to rid our highways of such automobiles is not only narrow but also shortsighted.

Real change must come from within and until we convince one another of the need to alter our day-to-day behavior — shutting windows when the heat’s on, hopping on a bus, flying in coach, exerting physical energy — we’re really not going to make much of a change at all. (Mike Tittinger, who lives in Santa Monica, is a regular columnist.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 16, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe