By IN YOUR SPACE BY CHRISTINA S. PORTER
On the real estate exam that I took many years ago, a sublease also was described as a “Sandwich Lease.”
This description makes sense in that the lessee’s position is literally “sandwiched” between the master lessor (landlord) and the sublessee. It does not, however, give you any indication of the precarious position of a sublessee.
In recent years there has been an inordinate amount of subleasing going on, particularly in the office market, providing bargain rates to sublessees. Knowing how to protect your possession of the premises prior to a commitment will save you time and money, later not losing the benefit of those bargain rates.
Although there are many things to consider when putting yourself in the vulnerable position of a sublessee, one very significant point to remember is that if the sublessor goes bankrupt — effectively creating a breach of their lease — the sublessee is left in a position of no control. The master lessor, at his option, but without any obligation to do so, may require that the sublessee “attorn” to it (meaning that the sublessee may become obligated to the master lessor instead of the sublessor while the master lessor takes on the responsibilities of the sublessor as determined in the sublease). However, in most cases the master lessor will not be liable for any security deposit or prepaid rent, or require that the sublessee vacate the premises immediately or in a manner previously agreed to in the master lease should a breach occur. Winding up in this situation could be particularly troublesome if the sublessee has invested money in tenant improvements, not to mention the catastrophic effect of having to move with little or no notice.
SOME PREVENTATIVE MEASURES: ■ Check the financial stability of the sublessor (credit check, financial statements, etc.). ■ Get written acknowledgment from the master lessor, prior to agreeing to the sublease, that it will act as a direct lease if the master lease is terminated, and the sublessee’s possession of the premises will not be disturbed. This is the best case scenario for a sublessee and could be difficult to obtain, particularly if the sublessee is paying less rent than the lessee is paying to the master lessor.
How much a master lessor will negotiate is, of course, situation specific, market driven and subject to the credibility of the sublessee. At the very least a sublessee should be given notice of the sublessor’s default and the right to cure with a fair amount of time provided to do so.
Last and most important, a sublessee should be sure to get a full copy of the master lease and review it prior to agreeing to the sublease. The execution of a sublease generally obligates the sublessee to the terms and conditions set forth in the master lease. The master lease will become a part of the sublease and the sublease is subordinate to the master lease.
If you are considering a sublease, check the proposed sublease document for the points described above. You will most likely discover that some or all of them may already be addressed in some fashion. Above all, be sure to run the document by your legal professional before signing. (Christina Porter specializes in the buinsess of leasing and selling office and industrial buildings. Contact her at (310) 806-6104, or e-mail to)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 28, 2004. Read the original PDF.