Press coverage of the budget crisis has focused on the basic political stalemate: Democrats want to avoid spending cuts, Republicans want to avoid new taxes. Nearly lost in this debate is the harm to children that would result from eliminating or greatly restricting children’s health insurance programs, as three proposals before the Legislature would do.
Under one proposal, 3 million low-income children covered under Medi-Cal would lose the guarantee of one full-year of health insurance coverage. In the last few years, California’s Medi-Cal program has wisely followed the private sector model of annual insurance renewals. But the Richman-Canciamilla budget proposal and Republican proposals in both the Assembly and Senate would eliminate the current guarantee of a full year of coverage once enrolled. With this shortsighted policy change, budget estimates are that nearly 500,000 children would lose their insurance coverage and California would lose the federal dollars that pay for 50 percent of Medi-Cal’s costs. Families whose children were mistakenly dropped would have to reapply for coverage and scarce public resources would be spent on administrative costs rather than on health care.
A second proposal would cause another 150,000 low-income children to lose their coverage under the Healthy Families program. Assembly Republicans have proposed to reduce the number of children eligible for Healthy Families, a successful program providing coverage to almost 700,000 children that is paid for with two-thirds Federal dollars. Not only would this reduction in Healthy Families disrupt children’s existing relationships with their doctors, children would end up in costly emergency rooms for their care. These cuts would also be a severe setback to a program that improves children’s health. A recent study released by the University of California, San Diego and the Children’s Hospital of San Diego — funded by the David and Lucile Packard Foundation — found that children enrolled in Healthy Families had better health and did better in school.
A third proposal would result in another 1 million children losing their access to basic immunizations and health screenings. Assembly Republicans have proposed to eliminate the Child Health and Disability Prevention (CHDP) program, which serves LETTERS, from page 4
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 26, 2003. Read the original PDF.