By Paul DeSantis, Yes On VERITAS Committee No living wage will help this kitchen man Editor:
Barbara Inatsugu, opinion in the Daily Press, Oct. 28, states that: 1) government officials should be elected by a majority vote, and 2) elections should be held when there is the highest voter turnout. It is not clear whether Ms. Inatsugu is speaking for the impartial branch of the Santa Monica League or for the advocacy/partisan branch, but in either case supporters of Measure HH (VERITAS) agree with both points.
Most people are shocked to discover that the Santa Monica League of Women Voters actually consists of two very different branches, the Voter Information branch, which impartially evaluates issues, and the “Action and Advocacy” branch, which acts as an advocate/partisan player in local debates. Unfortunately, League members have not made clear to the voters which branch is speaking nor has the Santa Monica League addressed the central problem with Santa Monica municipal elections.
Here in progressive Santa Monica, we have an invidious distinction: No one on our city council has been elected by a majority vote in over 20 years! Sadly, during these two decades the Santa Monica League has provided no solution to reform Santa Monica’s shamefully undemocratic election system. The California League of Women Voters, on the other hand, to its credit issued a formal position calling for election by a majority vote.
The American primary is the time-proven way to promote election by a majority vote. The primary election reduces a large number of candidates down to two candidates who then compete in the November general election. This system has worked well for 200 years throughout the U.S.A. Here in California, as well as in the rest of the nation, we use the primary system to choose our state and national office-holders.
Measure (HH) VERITAS will add Santa Monica’s nonpartisan primary elections for the city council and the mayor to the California spring primary, the same day we go to the polls to elect our state, national, and county officials and to vote on important state and county ballot measures. It is very difficult, of course, to win a majority vote (50 percent +1) in the primary because usually there are a large number of candidates. In most cases, no one will receive a majority vote, hence, the two candidates receiving the highest votes will participate in the November run-off election. This means that the most important election, the run-off, will be held in the November general election when the largest number of voters go to the polls.
Another major advantage of the American primary system is that it provides sufficient time for voters to carefully study the candidates, to watch how they conduct themselves during the campaigns, and to determine their real agenda. This is a crucial informational process. We need time for voter to learn about the candidates and for community involvement.
Inatsugu also discussed costs. The city’s cost will be minimal to implement a primary and district elections. Of utmost importance, Measure HH (VERITAS) will drastically reduce the candidate’s cost to run for office. In today’s very expensive city-wide elections, each candidate must reach 84,000 people, in HH’s seven neighborhood districts, a candidate only needs to reach approximately 12,000 people. District elections have worked well in cities similar in size to Santa Monica, including Berkeley, Pasadena, Redondo Beach, Watsonville, and others. In those cities, the cost to run for city council is a mere fraction of the cost to run for the Santa Monica City Council.
Let us be very clear: We believe that it is anti-democratic for ANY big money special interest group to dominate the election process, REGARDLESS OF WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM — big labor, big business or a home-grown big money political machine like SMRR. Today, independents who typically raise $9,000 or less cannot compete against candidates who are backed by the big money SMRR political machine which spends $250,000 on several professional, city-wide mailers, political consultants, and telephone “boiler rooms” which call to “ID” voters. In 20 years, only a handful of independent candidates have raised a war chest large enough, $80,000 or more, needed to challenge the Leviathan political machine. In fact, the majority of independents can’t afford even the $18,000 cost for just one city-wide mailing.
If any big money group attempts to dominate Measure HH (VERITAS) district elections, it can be defeated by grass-roots “People Power.” David can defeat Goliath big money campaigns. On their home turf, David (and Deborah!) have a huge advantage — they are already known to many of their neighbors who have met them at PTA groups, ball games, places of worship and other community events. An endorsement from someone you know is far more persuasive than a glossy slate mailer. Meeting the candidate at a neighborhood coffee or picnic is far more effective than a call from a “telephone boiler room.” With a good pair of walking shoes, candidates and their supporters can walk their districts to personally meet the voters.
Today, in progressive Santa Monica the city council is dominated by entrenched politicians who stay on, and on, and on, and on. One career office holder is working on 14 consecutive years! Even the powerful governor of California and the president of the U.S. are limited to eight years in office. HH provides that after serving two consecutive four-year terms, the candidate must stand down for four years but after that, if the voters wish, a candidate may return to the same office. HH’s progressive approach opens up the system to new blood and fresh ideas while also allowing good leaders to return to office. (For more details, see www.yesonveritas.org.) The system is broken: In over two decades, no Santa Monica official has been elected by a majority vote, the election system has been closed to ordinary citizens, and our city council has been clogged with career office holders. It is no surprise that the entrenched politicians who have benefited from this corrupt system now fear Measure HH (VERITAS) reforms. Asking the entrenched politicians on the city council to reform the system which gives them almost unlimited power is like asking hungry foxes to design a security system for the chicken coop!
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 30, 2002. Read the original PDF.