By Caroline Bodkin
I don’t know when I was kicked out of the single girls’ club, but it must have been sometime before last Wednesday afternoon, when I found myself in hour two of a phone call with a girlfriend of mine. She was upset with me; she feels I’ve been neglectful for the past year, since I started dating my boyfriend. She says I’ve become “one of those girls,” that I’ve been out of touch, don’t invite her over, don’t call … That I’m not living for myself anymore. Huh.
It’s bothered me ever since. I’m that girl? I’ve never been that girl. First, “that girl” isn’t a good friend. I think I am a good friend. Second, “that girl” has a hard time being single (she’s the type who always has a serious boyfriend). I didn’t become un-single because I was miserable while single — just the opposite. I was good at it. I had foreign countries to visit, schools to go away to, cities that held my destiny and I chose all those places and events proudly unencumbered — probably too proudly. My college girl-friends predicted I’d be the last in our group to marry. And as far as I’m concerned, I’m still making choices for myself even though I have someone else I consider. But apparently that doesn’t cut it. I’m out. No more membership for me. I’m “that girl.”
I felt my un-singleness again over the weekend at Book Club. We, 10 single women around my age, started talking about being single in the big city, far from home, having left our young-to-marry, suburban friends behind. Phrases like “I can barely take care of myself, I can’t deal with someone else,” “I don’t want to have to answer to anyone” and “I like not having to care how clean my apartment is” were bouncing back and forth amongst the group. These phrases were all things I might have said before, but I sat there in a group of peers, feeling unjustly like an outsider, thinking defensively “I came out here alone! I came out here feeling all those things! I’m still figuring things out even though I have a boyfriend! I make my own choices even though now I’ve got someone.”
I’m that girl? I’ve never been that girl. When I finally fell in love and got to tell my old friends — the ones who have been in or are in serious relationships — that I now know what they’ve been talking about (it’s nice to share your life with someone when you’re ready to do the sharing), I heard not only joy for me in their voices, I also heard real relief. Caroline’s not going to maintain her “I am an island” status forever. Thank god.
So how I got from that place — Caroline Island, USA — to last Wednesday, hour two of my phone-a-thon, to being ousted from The Single Girls’ Club, a.k.a. book club, and verbally spat on by my friend, I have no idea.
Here’s the irony: The most constant advice I give to people is “your feelings are valid, do what your heart tells you to do, even if it’s not what you think you’re supposed to do.” Sometimes this means going off to study health epidemics in Edinburough or chasing your dreams in NYC — just have the courage to be you, by yourself or otherwise.
Well now, for me, it means being me and learning how to do it with someone else. But it’s the same advice. I’m still myself, still struggling, still following my heart, but doing it in part by sharing my life with someone else. To me, it’s part of the same follow-your-heart idea.
I guess to single girls who are still doing it all on their own, it just looks like a cop out. But it doesn’t feel like one. Once scared to commit, happily single me just moved in with my boyfriend! And it feels like just as much of an adventure and risk as anything else I’ve ever done.
Where’s the line between living for yourself and choosing to share your life with someone?
Back at book club, sitting there amongst 10 women I consider my peers, I realized something. Maybe it’s not about doing it alone or with someone, being an island or being that girl. Maybe it’s just about doing it, whatever it is, however things change, the best you can. For me, I’m learning how to do this.
When I got home I called the friend and invited her over. We had wine, and when my boyfriend (we now live together) got home, we all spent some time. My life’s changed, but my values haven’t. Maybe it’s just about finding the best way to be a good friend, regardless of how life changes, and giving friends time to accept your changes as they can. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and wonders daily if she’ll miss her calling. You can )
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 2, 2004. Read the original PDF.