Skip to content

Santa Monica Living in a fantasy world

Published:

By Tom Larmore Santa Monica

Lori Klaidman’s recent letter takes those of us who oppose Measure JJ to task for three of the many arguments we have used to support our position. Unfortunately, she is wrong about one and misses the point with the others.

First, Ms. Klaidman says that Measure JJ exempts charities. It doesn’t. Any non-profit, which, for example, receives funding from the city to carry out social services, is obligated to pay those employees working on the contract the $12.25 minimum wage.

Second, she complains about our argument that the union exemption permits unionized hotels like the Viceroy to pay wages lower than the law requires of others. The point was not that all businesses should be covered or that the Viceroy contract is unfair to its workers, but only that this is an example of a major flaw in the measure. If non-union hotels are obligated to pay $10.50 plus benefits, why aren’t union hotels? If the Viceroy is essentially receiving credit for providing a generous benefits package, why aren’t non-union hotels which provide similar benefits entitled to the same credit?

Third, she suggests that we are disingenuous in our claims concerning the discriminatory aspects of Measure JJ. On the contrary, this is, and has always been, one of our major objections to the law.

What can possibly be sensible about discriminating among employees and employers based upon where the employer is located or whether it happens to be above or below some arbitrary revenue threshold?

The problem is that Measure JJ is an ill-conceived law designed to benefit only the local union, not workers. Businesses have to control costs in order to survive. Increasing the hourly wage, particularly when the major beneficiaries will be tipped workers already earning much higher incomes, will do little more than force employers to reduce hours, demand greater productivity and hire more highly skilled and experienced workers.

Many JJ supporters, perhaps including Ms. Klaidman, live in a fantasy world in which all one needs to do to achieve some social goal is pass a law mandating the desired result. Unfortunately, the market often responds in a way which frustrates those goals leading to the need to adopt yet more laws in a cycle that, at least in this case, is unlikely to end happily for any of us.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 1, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe