By Marc Schrobilgen Santa Monica
I have to empathize with Landmark’s Commissioner Barbara Schnitzler’s bewilderment that many people still believe that the Landmarks Commission must approve interior changes to historic homes.
Even though the current municipal code doesn’t make any exclusions for interiors, it “regulates and controls the alteration, restoration, construction, removal, relocation or demolition, in whole or in part, of or to a Structure of Merit, a Landmark or Landmark Parcel, or of or to a building or structure within a Historic District.”
I can tell you first hand that the Landmarks Commission could care less about the interior of your homes.
A year and a half ago my home had serious foundation, dry rot and termite problems, outdated and hazardous plumbing and electrical issues, and environmentally unsafe toxic mold and asbestos implications. Yet, when I filed for a demo permit, the Landmarks Commission stepped in at the 11th hour and without batting an eye designated my home as a Structure of Merit.Their findings were based on the criteria that it contributed to a potential historic district — a potential historic district that was listed on the inventory in1986 but for 15 years had stood stagnate.
Oh but the caring doesn’t stop there. After pleading that this would financially devastate me, they still wanted me to salvage my crumbling, dilapidated old home without any commissioner even stepping foot in it. It was alarming to me that the Landmarks Commission had the authority to make life altering decisions on the most important and substantial investment of my life just by driving by the front of it and liking what they saw.
After all, isn’t my house private property, don’t we live in America, and shouldn’t I have a voice in what happens to it? Fifteen months and $120,000 in expenses later, I was graciously granted a demo permit after my neighbors came to my rescue and vehemently opposed a district.
The Homeowners for Voluntary Preservation initiative, that would allow homeowners to give their consent before the city can come in and designate their homes, has been so popular that the Landmarks Commission has hastily drafted a confusing, at best, counter ordinance to thwart the hard work and conviction of the homeowners of Santa Monica. Unfortunately, the Landmark Commission does not think that the good people of Santa Monica can be trusted with such a responsibility.
Although the proposed ordinance has some good incentives and deals with problems under the current ordinance, it is still half-baked. The commission needs to understand that once voluntary preservation is in place and they compliment it with their outreach programs, incentives and education, they will accomplish what they want, which is a heightened preservation awareness and community involvement. Unfortunately for me, I was made aware of preservation because of my mandatory involvement.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 10, 2002. Read the original PDF.