Skip to content

Santa Monica The league’s disservice

Published:

How can we trust the League of Women Voters’ opinions, such as those offered in Joanne Leavitt’s Oct. 9 letter to the editor, when the due diligence required to obtain accurate facts is clearly missing? In August 2001, Leavitt and other members of the League’s board took the unprecedented step of opposing the Veritas (Measure HH) Charter Reform BEFORE it qualified for the ballot. The board did not follow the league’s motto “first study and then act.” It acted hastily without adequate study, without even allowing Veritas supporters the courtesy to appear and speak, and without the approval of the League’s membership, many of whom support Veritas (Measure HH).

The board then issued astonishingly inept press releases riddled with factual errors. One release stated that Veritas would reduce the residency requirement for mayor and council candidates from two years to 30 days, thus “newcomers to Santa Monica could run for office or be appointed to the council with very little knowledge of the city.”

For 27 YEARS, the California residency requirement has been 30 DAYS. Surely Leavitt or one of the other board members should have known such a well known fact. If not, the board should have “first studied, then acted” rather than issuing press releases with the ridiculous claim that Veritas changed the requirement when the 30 days residency has been the law for more than a generation of voters.

The press releases also erroneously charged that Veritas violated California’s one-subject rule. Again, how can people who hold themselves out as voting experts not know, or take the time to find the facts? The California Supreme Court states: “It is enough that the various provisions are reasonably related to a common theme or purpose.”

Moreover, the board’s hastily written press releases were inconsistent with the League’s California and national policies. The California League voted to “Support election systems for executive offices, both at the state and local levels, that require the winner to receive a majority of the votes.” Surely, the board members who are supposed to be experts on elections knew that in two decades, not one Santa Monica Council member was elected by a majority vote! Did the board understand Veritas’ run-off system which will assure election by a majority vote of the mayor and the council members?

The national league voted to “Promote the election of the president and vice-president by direct popular vote and work to abolish the electoral college.” Why does the board oppose Veritas’ direct election of the mayor in Santa Monica?

Perhaps the board would also like to explain an apparent conflict of interest. Why did the board hold “in cooperation with the City of Santa Monica” a meeting on “Alternative Voting Systems” which specifically excluded any discussion of neighborhood based districts? The board knew that the Veritas district initiative, signed by more than 9,000 voters, was an important alternative voting system worthy of serious Measure JJ: A law of, by and for the union

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 15, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe