Skip to content

Letter: Hotel manager questions union organizer's living wage advocacy

Published:

By Klaus Mennekes Hotel Casa del Mar General manager and vice president Santa Monica

During her entire time promoting the living wage, Vivian Rothstein always identified herself as a local activist and leader of Santa Monicans Allied for Responsible Tourism, hiding the fact that she was a paid union organizer. It was only after my disclosure that she confirmed being a member of H.E.R.E. Obviously, being paid $65,000 per annum by out of town interests may not have lent too much credibility to her cause or made for good public relations.

Her devotion to improve the lives of thousands of workers in Santa Monica hotels is specifically targeted to only those who work in a very specific geographic location in businesses with specific revenue criteria, in short, all those hotels she is being paid to unionize. So far, she has not had too much success convincing these employees that she really has their best interests in mind. Ms. Rothstein, her union and SMART supporters defend and promote a living wage ordinance and urge voters to do likewise. Why then, Ms. Rothstein, are the workers of your union specifically excluded from any passage of a living wage ordinance? Generating union dues and fattening union coffers is the bottom line of the business you represent. Too bad if the employees get shortchanged in accomplishing that objective.

For the benefit of the voters, here is paragraph 7 in the Collective Bargaining Agreement between the two Santa Monica union hotels and Local 814: “7. Preemption and Coordination (a) Intent of the Parties. The wages and economic benefits provided to Hotel employees pursuant to this Agreement were agreed upon by the parties as the result of collective bargaining pursuant to and in full compliance with federal law. It is therefore the intention and understanding of the parties that no ordinance, regulation or similar pronouncement by the City of Santa Monica may be interpreted to require an increase in or modification of the wages or economic benefits for the covered classifications set forth in Appendix A. Local 814 specifically agrees that it will not use or attempt to use such an ordinance, regulation or similar pronouncement of the City of Santa Monica as the basis of any legal or public argument that wages and/or economic benefits set forth herein should be increased.”

Ms. Rothstein states in her letter that she feels a responsibility to correct an unjust situation. She obviously now should know where to start!

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 12, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe