Skip to content

Say what? President ducked hard questions during speech

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

President George W. Bush on Tuesday addressed the nation. He spoke for just over 30 minutes, but I’m not all that sure what he said. I mean, what was his point, exactly? That we, Americans, are just supposed to have resolve and be patient until we meet with success in Iraq? Is that right?

OK. I have no problem with being patient and sticking it out. In fact, I believe that we need to stay in Iraq until the country has stabilized and the insurgent threat has greatly diminished. If we leave, I think we’ll have greater problems in the Middle East than we can even fathom. My position should not be a surprise to anyone who knows me — I have never been against this war, I have only always been against the way we have been conducting it (see Here’s The Thing in the SMDP, April 22, 2004).

But I am not the president, and it is not my job to define success, which is why, my question for President Bush is this: What do you consider to be a success? Because as far as I can tell ever since this war began we’ve been pursuing a moving target.

First, we were told that success meant bringing down Saddam’s regime. We did that — shock and awe, statute fell, took over Baghdad, even caught Saddam.

Next, we were told that success meant eliminating the threat of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. We did that — none were found.

Then we were told that success rode on the transfer of sovereignty to the Iraqis. We met that goal two days early in June of 2004. Anyone remember L. Paul Bremer? Then we were told success would come with the Iraqi election. Done — lots of women with purple ink on their fingers.

Now what? Are we supposed to believe that success will come once the Iraqis finish writing their constitution in August? Will the insurgents stop their attacks once there is a permanent government?

Or does Bush mean that until we the train enough Iraqis to protect Iraq, there will be no success, no matter what? If this is the case, then how many trained Iraqis are enough to keep the peace?

Or does he mean that success won’t be achieved until we have wiped out the insurgent threat and the Iraqi people are up and running with their own government? Or does he mean that success won’t occur until we have dismantled the terrorist cells that are now operating in Iraq and have been flocking there since the fall of Saddam’s regime?

Here’s The Thing: When moderate Democrats like Indiana Sen. Evan Bayh and conservative Republicans like South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham both start asking for measures of success, they’re not asking for timelines. President Bush ducked the hard question and chose instead to answer the easy one. No one needs a date certain. All everyone wants is to understand what the goal is in this war.

At the moment, President Bush’s definition for success appears to be bringing democracy to the region and spreading freedom around the world. While this is a laudable and worthy goal, I almost hate to tell him that we — here in America — are still working on getting both freedom and democracy right. And we’ve been doing it ever since Thomas Jefferson famously wrote in the Declaration of Independence: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness.”

As our own Independence Day — July 4th — approaches, I urge you to each take a few moments away from the barbecue and the beer. Read a couple of our government’s sacred documents — the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Emancipation Proclamation, the Supreme Court’s decision from Brown vs. the Board of Education of Topeka. Honor our troops by honoring all those who, like them, have fought for liberty and democracy — from Patrick Henry to George Washington to Frederick Douglass to Elizabeth Cady Stanton to General George S. Patton to Martin Luther King, Jr.

Then ask Bush what his real goal is for this war, and when he will be willing to declare it a success? Because it’s not about democracy and freedom, it’s about how much democracy and freedom do we believe has to exist in Iraq for us to be safe in America. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D.,)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 1, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe