Skip to content

School district shouldn’t be on the defensive

Published:

By Michael Cohen Santa Monica

I am a Samohi parent, and I would like to offer a few comments about the recent events at Samohi where racist graffiti was sprayed on various school buildings. In the intervening week or so, I have received an e-mail from the principal, Dr. Straus, and an e-mail from our house principal. There has also been a somewhat volatile PTSA meeting, which got a fair amount of TV news coverage. I did not go to the meeting but my wife did.

I understand that the parents of kids whose safety is jeopardized by these events would point fingers (in some cases literally) at the Samohi administration and the school district because they are the only available “stationary targets.” I think it is very important to keep in perspective, however, that the real wrongdoers here are the graffiti taggers and that any failings of the school or the district are, in all likelihood, no more than a small factor in the taggers’ disgusting behavior. In fact, I understand that it was mentioned at the PTSA meeting that there is some suspicion that the hateful graffiti was the work of individuals who are not Samohi students.

The e-mail from Dr. Straus “apologizes” for the events that occurred. For the last year or so, the school administration and the school district have bent over backwards to accommodate the community input it received as to what needs to be done to prevent these ugly incidents. For example, security has been beefed up, “outreach specialists” have been hired, and the freshman seminar curriculum has been modified to include a “cultural sensitivity” component. It seems to me, therefore, that the administration is just as much a victim of these criminal acts as everybody else in the community. While I understand that an “apology” may seem like an appropriate conciliatory gesture designed to help calm the situation, I am concerned that the defensive posture of an apology will lead to a situation where the school and the district are blamed rather than the wrongdoers themselves.

There will undoubtedly be calls, and there already have been calls, for the school and the district to “do something.” Of course, the safety of the students is a priority and at least a short-term enhancement of security seems necessary. My concern is that a desire to placate some unhappy community members with additional amorphous programs will overwhelm other objectives that should be considered, such as spending our money in a fiscally responsible way and ensuring that students get the best possible education. By the way, I don’t mean to be too cynical with my comment about “amorphous programs,” but when Dr. Straus talks in her e-mail about providing “house and school social action opportunities and strategies,” I think I can legitimately express concern about programs being amorphous.

The e-mail from the house principal indicates that consideration is being given to spending a portion of English or history class time “addressing the issues.” What happens then to the curriculum that was supposed to be covered on those days? Are AP history students or remedial English students, for example, better served by spending class time discussing why it’s bad to spray racist graffiti than spending that time working, respectively, on material that will be covered on the AP test or getting their English skills up to speed so they can graduate on time?

My understanding is that the district, like pretty much every school district in California, is perpetually in dire financial circumstances. My assumption, therefore, is that every dollar of revenue the district anticipates is fully budgeted to be spent for some important purpose. To the extent that any steps taken to “do something” in the hope of preventing future problems involving racial tensions require financial expenditures of any significance, I would like to know where the revenue is coming from or, more likely, what other expenses are being cut as a consequence. It may well be that a proposed expense for mitigating racial tensions is a better use of funds than the alternative expense currently budgeted, but at least that trade-off should be directly and openly discussed.

Finally, and this is a relatively minor point, I’m wondering what happened to the snazzy security camera system that was installed at Samohi last year with some fanfare and, I assume, some considerable cost. If I recall correctly, the response to those who expressed concern about an infringement on students’ privacy was along the lines of, “Don’t worry, these are primarily intended to capture acts of vandalism.” Now that there has been a terrible act of vandalism, I think we, the parents and taxpayers, are entitled to a report on whether these cameras worked or whether they were a waste of money.

In summary, my hope is that Samohi and the school district focus their efforts on continuing to improve the quality of the education that our kids are receiving, as evidenced by last year’s outstanding test scores. While unfortunate incidents such as the racist graffiti cannot and should not be ignored, our school system should not accept “blame” for these incidents and, in deciding what response, if any, is appropriate, should not overlook its other goals and responsibilities. Oh, and please tell us about the camera system.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 13, 2006. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe