Skip to content

School tax a risk and a waste

Published:

By David Marks Santa Monica

The Santa Monica Daily Press asked last week in its Q-Line question, “Is it fair that 15 percent of cash donations be distributed throughout all schools in the district?” I ask whether it is fair that the SMDP asks the question in such a biased and inaccurate way?

What I if rephrased your question and asked “Is it fair that I cannot donate money to my children’s school, without the district taking a meaningful portion of my donation away from my children’s school?” My question would be just as biased as yours. Your question was also inaccurate since the current proposal includes taxing non-cash donations the same way as cash.

This is a divisive issue for what had been a united community. We all recognize the benefits of our outstanding Santa Monica schools. We also know that California’s budget crisis threatens funding for public education. As a parent of two Franklin Elementary students, I know I speak for many who understand just how fortunate we are to have such a generous and enlightened community. We truly benefit from an environment in which a strong partnership exists between the district, teachers, the school PTAs, the Santa Monica City Council, the local merchants, and so many others who work so hard to do whatever they can to make up some of the gap of the state funding levels. Understand that not just money is donated, but also computers, books, food for carnivals, gifts for auctions, as well as hundreds of volunteer hours in our schools.

Superintendent John Deasy knows we have a serious funding crisis. Now is the worst time to jeopardize any of the generosity our schools receive today. We need everyone who supports our schools to be as enthusiastic as possible about their gifts. The better they feel, the more donations our schools will receive. Let’s not kid ourselves. If we do not allow people to choose which groups receive their donations, we will lose donations. How can Deasy just rationalize away this risk? Why even take the risk?

The sad part is that controversy and debate has already hurt our schools. Instead of spending time arguing about this issue, people on both sides would have made a greater impact focusing that same energy on raising even more support for our schools’ growing needs. What a waste.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 16, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe