By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger announced on Monday that he was calling a special election for Nov. 8 to place before the voters three measures that the Democratically-controlled Legislature refused to negotiate with him over: (1) spending caps for the budget; (2) teacher tenure and (3) redistricting. On Tuesday, Democrats abruptly shifted course, abandoning the budget fight that they had been preparing for since the governor had offered his May revise.
Despite low poll ratings, Schwarzen-egger continues to play politics better than any of the Democratic politicians in Sacramento. In other words, he’s on the way to getting most of his budget through the Legislature, and he’s getting a special election later this year.
All the Democrats are getting is an expensive fight that will force them to choose between campaigning against the 2005 initiatives and preparing for the 2006 election cycle. It won’t be easy for State Treasurer Phil Angelides and State Controller Steve Westly, both of whom want to take on the governor in 2006, to outflank him on the ballot initiatives and to raise money for their primary campaigns. It won’t be easy for the California Democratic Party to wage back-to-back campaigns, after already having fought three statewide campaigns in the past three years.
This was supposed to be an off-year. The “out-party” was supposed to be using this time to focus on strategy, message, and money — planning how to oust the “in-party.”
When there is no downtime, there is no reflection. There is only reaction, and while reaction is usually good enough to obstruct policies, it’s rarely good enough to replace incumbents.
So how did the Democrats let themselves get outmaneuvered by a governor who can’t even give a speech at his alma mater — Santa Monica College — without being drowned out by protesters?
Schwarzenegger used the Democrats’ hubris. He’s been talking about a special election since January. He made it clear that if the Democrats refused to address his top priorities, then he would take the issues directly to the people and call a special election for the fall.
The Democrats balked. They said Schwarzenegger’s priorities were “vanity” issues. They ignored him. Then they attacked him. They had union activists upset with his budget proposal — nurses, teachers, and government employees — hound him at every public event. They ran paid advertisements maligning him and his budget. They believed that if the governor’s poll numbers dropped and he became unpopular, then he wouldn’t call for a special election — all evidence to the contrary.
Through the winter, Schwarzenegger continued raising money and talking about his priorities. He stayed on track, even as he took his knocks: Pension plans were shelved and the merit pay proposal for teachers went by the wayside. In May, he presented a revised budget that was well received by the non-partisan legislative analyst’s office.
And this was where and when the Democrats made their major misstep. Instead of working to bridge the divide on the budget and the special election issue, the Democrats decided to offer their own budget, which included a proposal to raise taxes (on the wealthy) to fund pre-K-12 education.
Never mind that general revenues are not that easily dedicated to policy areas because of previous statutory requirements. Never mind that most Californians do not distinguish between “raising taxes” and “raising taxes on the wealthy.” Never mind that Democrats were branded “tax and spend” liberals in the 1980s, and their policy proposal fit that label well.
Simply put, only Willie Brown or Jesse Unruh could have pulled off this kind of a power play.
At an event on Tuesday, Schwarz-enegger said it all: “They (Democrats) want to back us into a corner so eventually they can force us to raise taxes. From now to election day, I want to talk about all the specific taxes (Democrats and their allies) want to change.” He even included in his list Proposition 13, despite the fact that it has no relationship to any of the ballot initiatives.
Here’s The Thing: If the Democrats had been serious about winning the 2006 elections, then they would have engaged in politics, not smear campaigns. Had they been willing to play ball with Schwarzenegger on his reform priorities, then they would have been able to negotiate for more of what they wanted — money for education and health care — on the budget. Not only might they have gotten reform bills they like, rather than ballot initiatives they despise, but they also might have prevented a special election.
As it is, Democrats can thank their representatives in the Legislature for undermining the party’s chances in not just one election, but two. Don’t be surprised if Arnold wins at least two out of three of his ballot initiatives and he gets reelected in 2006. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester at California State University, Channel Islands. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 17, 2005. Read the original PDF.