By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Last week, Senate President Pro Tem Don Perata (D-Oakland) was quoted in the Los Angeles Times as saying: “With regard to redistricting, it’s really an intramural game. I know people don’t get up in the morning in my district, make coffee and then decide (they are) worried about redistricting.”
In another article, Assembly Speaker Fabian Nuñez (D-Los Angeles) referring to redistricting told a reporter: “If he (Schwarzenegger) calls a special election that is of no concern to the public and only to political insiders, then it’s going to be more difficult for us to hold hands and walk down the aisle together.”
I’ve never been more embarrassed to be a Democrat than when I read these two statements, which so clearly betrayed both leaders’ elitist attitudes and insider status. Not only do they seem confused about what the Democratic Party stands for, but these elected officials also seem to have forgotten what it means to represent people.
And we have their gerrymandered districts to thank, since neither one had a race last year.
In November, Perata received 77 percent of the total votes cast in his district, and in the March primary, no Democrat chose to run against him, so he won 100 percent of the Democratic vote. Nuñez fared equally well. In the general, he won 85 percent, and in the primary, he, too, received 100 percent.
Admittedly, most people do not concern themselves with the details of redistricting, nor do they realize how profoundly it has affected their electoral choices over time, but most voters do know that their representatives never seem to have competition.
What is worse is that when their representatives do have competition, it’s usually during the primary when the candidates try to outdo each other on ideological extremism and partisan rhetoric — the Democrats battle on the left and the Republicans battle on the right. A chasm develops where centrists in both parties and non-partisan moderates are ignored or ostracized, making turnout abysmally low and the ideologue the winner.
In last year’s election, all of California’s incumbents affected by redistricting who stood for reelection won — 51 members in the U.S. House of Representatives, 10 state senators and 56 state assemblymembers. Are they really all that good? And in the seats that were open due to term limits — 18 in the State Assembly and eight in State Senate — not one changed party hands.
Simply put, voters are not able to affect their representation because competition doesn’t exist. Unless an individual moves to a district that places them among a like-minded majority, they are unlikely to be heard through their vote.
Having analyzed four decades of California’s redistricting plans in a recent political science quarterly (see: “It Pays To Pay A Professional: California’s Redistricting Compromise of 2002” at www.larambrownphd.com/pas/july04- EOR.pdf), not only is the decline in competition marked after the 2002 redistricting plan, but it also becomes clear that the plans that brought the most competition were those that were done by “Special Masters” commissions comprised of former judges. This is not to say that judges are not biased in a partisan manner — because they are — but what makes them superior at redistricting is that they do not possess the same interest in incumbency protection as the members of California’s legislature.
Suggestions to tie redistricting to term-limit extensions would actually bring back some level of rationality to our state government. Term limits were enacted to “throw out the career politicians” who kept getting reelected, but what the reformers back then didn’t seem to realize was that gerrymandering was the problem.
If you have competitive districts, then incumbents must either (a) represent their constituents well, or (b) face serious competition in the next election. Competition is the best term limit you can ever impose. It not only works to make the representative more accountable to the voter, but it also helps to reduce the number of ideologues in office, which means more work and less grandstanding in government.
Here’s the Thing: Elections should not be rigged prior to the campaign even beginning. The partisan registration in each district should be as balanced as possible, allowing for contiguous areas and minority representation.
Although I might have issues with some of Gov. Schwarzenegger’s budget reforms — namely his suggested changes to Proposition 98 and the proposal for an across-the-board cut when the budget falls out of balance — I stand in support of his efforts to address redistricting.
Once again, as a moderate Democrat, I find that I am more pleased than angered by the governor’s actions. I didn’t vote for him in 2003, but I just might in 2006. As for Perata and Nuñez, my only hope is that they actually have to face an unrigged electorate one day. They might not find it as welcoming as the Democratic caucus.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 14, 2005. Read the original PDF.