Skip to content

The verdict is in: American juries need reform

Published:

POLITIGIRL

By BETH SOLOMON

In Washington, politics is everywhere. Living here means participating in politics, whether you like it or not. Whether you vote or not.

Jim Hayter avoided voting for three decades. But early this year, he registered. It was a casual decision, he said ñ he checked a box on his driver’s license renewal form, and voila — Jim Hayter became a registered voter, prepared for one of the most contentious elections in history.

But Hayter wasnít prepared for a biblical-style flood of jury summons he would receive due to that seemingly innocent flick of the pen. In one year, Hayter has been asked to serve on three local and federal juries.

It’s an untenable situation for an entrepreneur like Hayter. Itís untenable for many people who have demanding careers.

“I’m so sorry that I registered to vote,”

Hayter, a former MCI executive, says ruefully. “I probably wonít even vote, but Iím paying for it anyway.”

The D.C. Superior and Federal courts are some of the most efficient bureaucracies operating here. So what’s wrong with this picture?

The truth is, other things are amiss in the American jury selection process. Juries tend to be populated by retired and unemployed people. They usually arenít representative of the average population. Yet, the decisions they make affect us profoundly.

I sat on a jury once. It was a murder trial. Serious stuff. I honestly felt that my fellow jurors were not able to adequately sort the facts. It wasn’t their fault.

But the situation, whether it’s about a homicide or medical malpractice, cries out for the most competent, truly representative juries we can find.

New legislation aims to alleviate the burdens of jury service and encourage all people to serve. It’s called the Jury Patriotism Act.

The legislation: ■ Allows jurors to reschedule their jury service around business and personal commitments by providing one automatic postponement of jury service. ■ Provides greater convenience for jurors by limiting jury duty to nor more than one day, unless the juror is selected to serve on a longer trial. ■ Limits the frequency upon which a citizen may be called to serve. ■ Protects small businesses by requiring courts to reschedule the service of an employee if another employee of that business is serving on a jury during the same period. ■ Provides additional compensation to jurors selected to serve on lengthy trials, thus encouraging participation by working people. A “lenthy trial fund” would provide income protection to any juror serving on a long trial who is not fully compensated by his or her employer during jury service.

The idea is to ensure that juries represent all the members of a community ñ including working people. The legislation would also limit excuses to true hardship and require everyone to serve.

“Making jury service more appealing and rewarding to citizens is so critical,” said Kristin Armshaw, director of the Civil Justice Task Force of the American Legislative Exchange Council. “Plaintiffs and defendants in both civil and criminal cases deserve to receive a fair trial before a true jury of their peers.”

In the past year, Arizona, Louisiana and Utah have enacted legislation to increase broad participation on juries. Similar legislation is pending in Vermont, Ohio and Colorado.

If we don’t change the system to recruit a more representative jury pool, jury duty becomes like the draft in Vietnam. Those who can avoid it — the priveledged, the wealthy, the politically connected — find a way out.

The verdict on such practices is clear — unequal participation hurts all of us. Our jury system can only achieve consistent, less arbitrary and fairer results if juries reflect a full range of knowledge and experience among jurors.

Uncle Sam ñ and the rest of us — need you. (Beth Solomon is reachable at) Finally, the imperceptiveness of Mr. Pisarra when it comes to the difficulties faced by a significantly physically disabled person such as Mr. Genser in getting dressed and then maintaining the finery of grooming during long days should raise some red flags when it comes to Mr. Pisarra’s ability to make quality judgments. As a person who is still able bodied, Mr. Pisarra should bless how quickly and easily he can slip in and out of a range of clothing designs each day and move his arms freely and without pain. Then he should spend just a little time watching how difficult it is for Mr. Genser to walk, move, or even swivel his neck. Instead of dragging Genser’s appearance into an issue that has nothing to do with grooming, polished shoes or cool clothing, he should give Genser an extra portion of respect for his commitment to public service despite his physical difficulties.

How would Mr. Pisarra like it if we ridiculed his name? Well, Mr. Genser may have more difficulty in changing his appearance than Pisarra would have in changing his name.

PS. In the same issue was a “Funny Paperz” cartoon critical of another City Councilman Michael Feinstein, which was critical but right on point in that it humorously pointed out how Feinstein was avoiding the central issue of his honesty — a valid public concern about any public official — by focusing on his commitment to grassroots campaigning. The cartoonist was pointing out the irrelevance of Feinstein’s responses. His glad handing of voters has nothing to do with whether he can be trusted with money. On the other hand, the political columnist Pisarra was committing an irrelevancy against a public figure: Genser’s dress and grooming disqualifies him from exercising aesthetic judgment on architecture or advocating that an architectural board exercise such judgment and the power to prevent gross building designs.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 30, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe