By Todd Flora
■ The Bush administration several months ago proposed the so-called “Healthy Forests” initiative. The plan was sold to the public as a way of using the “good science” this president is allegedly so fond of to remove lower-growth dead brush from our nation’s forests that surround our larger, majestic trees. By “thinning” the forests of this low growth, they argue, we would eliminate ground fuel that ultimately serves as “kindling” for major forest fires.
If the explanation were that simple, it would not be such bad policy. While I agree ridding this (supposedly dead) brush would lower temperatures in the heart of a fire and slow the pace of fires by starving them of fuel, on general principle I have to question any plan that involves George W. Bush.
And wouldn’t you know it, upon further examination, Bush’s “forest thinning” initiative doesn’t fund an adequate budget for forest workers to carefully remove harmful low-growth “kindling” in a targeted, measured way. It would simply allow contractors and logging companies to “clear cut” forests. Clear cutting is of course an unnecessary and reckless approach to logging that uses an almost “nuclear” approach to clearing land.
What’s the thinking here? Hey, we would lose a lot of our nation’s most precious old growth trees, but at least we would eliminate the brush that might destroy them anyway in a forest fire! Please. Using this logic, we should smart bomb every neighborhood where a criminal is on the run. We might lose a few hundred residents, but at least we will have protected them from a dangerous criminal.
And speaking of smart bombs, why aren’t American forests as worthy of the precision necessary to protect large, old growth trees as Baghdad neighborhoods were when we supposedly “avoided” killing so many innocent Iraqi civilians during the “Shock and Awe” campaign?
In addition, many of the forests targeted for “thinning” by Bush and Co. are nowhere near population centers of concern. Instead, these sites are an excuse to allow logging interests to produce more unnecessary, wasteful logging roads. Timber interests often like to disguise their over-destruction by arguing clearing roads is necessary to produce natural fire breaks. But all it really does is waste taxpayer funds on clearing dirt roadways for the timber industry’s trucks.
The fires that have ravaged Southern California have catalyzed Congress into action. The U.S. House and Senate are now trying to reconcile bills that would expedite approval of several forest thinning efforts.
Our own Sen. Diane Feinstein supports one proposal that is considered a moderate alternative to Bush’s fixation on destroying as many national forests as possible during his term in office.
While certainly better than the conservative House counterpart, the Feinstein alternative has raised some questions about whether it would truly protect old-growth forests.
What’s more troubling than the Bush administration’s shameless and overt approach to opening up our national forests to logging interests is the lack of public outrage that comes with it. Why do moderate, independent voters continue to even give President Bush the benefit of the doubt? There is no doubt about this president’s stand on the environment. His ideology is search, destroy and let big corporations profit. Perhaps it seems almost too unbelievable to allow ourselves room for the idea that someone’s intentions could really be that sinister. Especially someone we (kind of) elected president. Well, believe it.
It’s time to take our protest into the voting booth in 2004. Regardless of what scientific approach is ultimately agreed to in dealing with forest protection, one sure-fire forest protection plan needs no study. It’s called, “get rid of George Bush.” (Todd Flora is a government relations professional and six year resident of Santa Monica. He is active in Heal the Bay, the Democratic Party and the living wage movement in Santa Monica. To respond or reach Todd, ).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 4, 2003. Read the original PDF.