Skip to content

Self-righteous strikers

Published:

By Michael Harrington

It is truly unfortunate that our community is riven by the supermarket strike, but the self-righteousness on the picket lines is misguided (SMDP, “Crossing picketers gets more harrowing,” Jan. 31, page 1). The grocery workers are just the latest casualty of a social benefit system gone awry and union harassing of customers is wrong and futile.

One underlying problem is a corporate tax system that allows employee health benefits to be expensed on the employers’ income statement. One National Bureau of Economic Research study has estimated that such tax subsidies have cost federal, state and local governments $100 billion in lost revenue. So contrary to popular belief, taxpayers have been subsidizing health benefits for grocery workers all along. Consumers and workers pay the rest through higher prices and lower wages. The idiocy here is that we treat a necessary benefit as a cost.

Unfortunately, this cozy structure is breaking down as workers throughout the economy are losing benefits as companies are forced to adjust to competitive economic pressures. Even with the tax subsidies, companies are being forced to jettison the high cost of benefits. The major supermarkets already are not competitive and the result of this strike is that they will be even less competitive in the future. For example, at Albertsons or Vons a half gallon of milk costs $2.29-2.79 while at Trader Joe’s it costs $1.69. The same cost savings apply to breads, cheeses, wines, cereals, bananas, butter, etc. We have other low cost alternatives nationwide in Costco, Walmart and Target.

I see no justification for grocery workers to ask consumers to pay the price for one side or the other in this suicide embrace between management and workers. One might argue that since we are all taxpayers and all workers (not quite true); why not make all such benefits compulsory? But why cross-subsidize health care for everyone? Wouldn’t it make more sense to eliminate the subsidy and just buy our own health care? Then government could target low-income citizens with subsidies. The world is changing and whatever the result of this strike, we will be forced to change with it.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 2, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe