Skip to content

Senator interprets state budget Guest Commentary

Published:

By Sheila Kuehl

This is the second in a series of articles from Sen. Sheila Kuehl (D-Santa Monica). The first article focused on how the state found itself in its budget crisis. Today’s article examines the present budget.

In the first essay, I talked about how we got into what most are calling “the budget mess”.

Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger is required to send his proposed budget to the Legislature in January of each year. Because Gov. Schwarzenegger had just been elected in the fall, much of the budget delivered to us in January had been pulled together by his transition team, which included several people who had worked in the Pete Wilson administration. Not surprisingly, it reflected a number of approaches seen in that administration.

Now, the four budget sub-committees in each house of the legislature are pulling the proposals apart, changing them in some ways.

The proposed budget for 2004-05 assumes that California personal income will grow 5.6 percent in 2004 and almost 6 percent in 2005. Altogether, the revenue projection side of the governor’s proposed budget assumes a growth in all taxes of about 6 percent over the previous year, about $2 billion.

Holdover expenses from the 2002-03 budget, which we keep dragging into the new budgets, seem to have diminished (better tax collections, lower expenditures and encumbrances) by about $2.1 billion so that the total debt brought into the current year is reduced from $10.7 billion to “only” $8.6 billion.

The administration proposes using $12.3 billion in proceeds to offset past debts and some of the current gap between revenue and expenditures in the 2004-05 budget.

Because the Schwarzenegger administration is still refusing to consider any tax increases at all, the budget is proposed to be balanced by cutting programs. The gap proposed to be filled by cuts is $6.5 billion. Remember, this is his proposed budget and does not yet reflect any changes made by the budget sub-committees in the legislature or “change of mind” switches by the governor.

Some of the big items to be cut: ■ $2 billion less to K-12 schools. ■ $950 million cut to transportation ■ $1.4 billion cut to social services, targeted in grant reductions, cutting cost-of-living adjustments and eliminating all the money the state pays for in-home supportive services. ■ $1.1 billion cut to Medi-Cal, mostly reflecting a 10 percent cut in what we pay doctors and a $400 million cut in medical services for prison inmates. ■ Cities, which were jubilant when the governor, having cut the vehicle license fee (VLF) (bad for the cities and counties which get about $4 billion a year directly, especially law enforcement and firefighters), told them he would (illegally) declare an emergency and appropriate an equal amount from the general fund to make sure they didn’t suffer (good for the cities and counties, who were then supposed to get all the money they would have gotten from the VLF if it had stayed at full strength), were then shocked to see that the governor had fooled them all and taken a like amount ($1.3 billion) away in property taxes. The cities are striking back with an initiative — more on that in a later missive. Endgame? Cities and counties down $1.3 billion, at least. ■ Local government loses even more when you consider the governor would remove funding for juvenile probation and reduce transportation spending. Another $600 million. ■ And, of course, higher education lost a large and disproportionate part of its budget, with UC and CSU hit the hardest, but student fees will rise on all campuses, while student aid is proposed to be cut.

Each of these areas will get an essay of its own, so you can see what the real results are and where, in the name of cuts, the budget might actually add to costs.

And … even with all these cuts, the budget will still be $783 million out of balance.

There is still a question about whether the bond the legislature adopted to fund state pensions will hold up in court and whether we can actually reduce Medi-Cal provider rates by 10 percent, since a court already threw out an action we had taken to reduce them by 5 percent in the current budget. And whether the revenue counted from tribal gaming in the budget can ever be collected. And whether the feds will pay us all the money they owe us.

Since several of you have praised the brevity of the first piece, I’ll stop here.

Next time: The impact of some of these cuts on education, K-12, community colleges, CSU and UC.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 5, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe