By Ed Silverstein
Today I spent a few moments at the memorial for the victims of last Wednesday’s tragedy.
The accident took the lives of 10 people, including two children, and injured at least 70 others. There are flowers, notes and the incongruous pink of a giant stuffed animal. Of course one victim is not being commemorated.
Russell Weller, the 86-year-old driver, probably had no business being behind the wheel. In a few short seconds he devastated many lives. But Weller lost everything as well. He will forever be haunted by a horrible legacy that has erased all the good he had accomplished throughout his life.
Subsequent civil actions will financially ruin him. He might even lose his freedom, deservedly so, if he is found to have been fleeing a previous accident when he tore through the market.
It would be easy to hate Mr. Weller. But what I feel is pity. Maybe because I realize that it could easily have been one of my own relatives behind that wheel.
I remember my grandfather, age 80, picking up my brother at the train station.
He had just dropped a 10mg Valium for a shoulder spasm. It didn’t occur to him that it might have an effect on his driving — like blowing through five stop signs without touching the brake. It took my stepfather four years to talk my grandfather into giving up his car. It will take a lot longer to get my stepfather to give up his keys, despite numbness in his legs that make it difficult for him to feel the pedals.
Then there’s my great aunt who would almost be funny if she weren’t so terrifying. She suffers from post polio syndrome. Her elbows are pinned to her side, her mobility limited to her wrists. Until recently she drove tag team with her boyfriend whose eyesight was nearly gone. She would call out instructions while he operated the controls. Now he’s blind and she’s driving solo, which is nearly as scary as suggesting to her that she quit. Thank God she’s in Florida.
So why do so many seniors continue to drive long after they are capable? Part of it is practical. Mass transportation is inadequate and often not easily accessible, particularly if someone has problems walking. Cabs are expensive. It’s often easier to get into the car and seniors reason (erroneously) that it’s safe to drive as long as they only go a few blocks or don’t make left turns.
Seniors feel that by giving up their cars they are also losing their autonomy and independence. And just as the loss of our parents removes a psychological barrier to our own mortality, so does the loss of our ability to drive force us to face the imminence of our own death.
Whatever the reason, there are too few elderly drivers giving up their licenses voluntarily. And the catalyst for those who do is often an accident or a close call. With people living and driving longer, we as a society have a responsibility both to the elderly themselves and to those they endanger.
With the exception of the AARP (and politicians dependent on their contributions) most agree that testing of seniors is desperately needed. Or as my 95-year-old (non-driving) grandmother puts it: “They should check their eyes, their body and their brains.” But at the same time we need to avoid the impulse to use this tragedy to enact impulsive legislation that is overreaching and unfair.
Seniors over 75 years old should be tested, but not in the same manner as 16-year-olds. So forget hand-signals and parallel parking. Especially parallel parking. And for that matter, forget the road test. It will cause needless stress, is expensive and is not a particularly effective method of testing seniors.
Driving simulators would be far better solution. And they would almost certainly be more cost effective. Unexpected driving situations, such as a car abruptly pulling away from a curb, could be programmed. Conditions that might be otherwise dangerous or impractical including left turns onto busy streets or driving at night could also be tested.
Another advantage of simulators is that they are impersonal and consistent. A scoring system could be created. Those who score highest would require less frequent testing regardless of their age. And those with low scores could be required to take another test in as little as six months. Seniors who have specific problems, such as driving at night, could be issued the limited daytime licenses such as those given to young drivers in certain states.
While testing is imperative, we must also be sensitive to seniors who lose their licenses. Policies are needed to prevent the elderly from becoming prisoners in their homes. Free local shuttles could be offered to provide better access to shopping and services. Taxi services should be encouraged to offer fare pooling, where the companies would put together seniors going to the same destination. The city might even consider offering partially subsidized taxi fares to low income seniors who don’t drive.
Whatever the eventual solutions, we must begin to act now. As a country we’re not getting any younger. In the meantime, I think I’ll have a talk with some of my family members. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica and the driving force behind Incites. Comments can be e-mailed to).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 23, 2003. Read the original PDF.