Skip to content

Setting the record straight about historical districts

Published:

By Barbara Schintzler

Guest Commentary by Barbara Schintzler

First to my resume. I am a “dunderhead, a self-serving bureaucrat, an unwitting twit, modern-day land grabber, self-righteous, callous, rude, idiotic.”

I am “Cruella DeVille.” I am also a 15-year resident of Santa Monica, a property owner, run an architectural design firm... and am a Landmarks Commissioner.

The names I’ve been called in the past few months are all related to my work in trying to carry out a policy of zoning and land use that balances the preservation of Santa Monica’s character with the interests of homeowners. The opponents of preservation have waged a campaign of misinformation and ridicule at such a fevered pitch that it will be difficult to sort out what’s true from what’s not. That said, here’s my attempt.

• In the 26 years since the landmark’s ordinance was adopted, 16 private residences have been landmarked and two historic districts were created. Hardly radical.

• We have NO jurisdiction over the interior of your home. Read section 9.36.140 of the Ordinance.

704,• If anyone tells you that property values will fall in a historic district, that is their personal, unsubstantiated guess. The studies which have been done show that property values have risen higher in historic districts than in other parts of the city.

• All potential landmark and district designations require noticing and public hearings. Your voice can be heard in this process. The commission cannot “ram a decision through.” Our meetings are public on the second Monday of the month at 7 p.m. at City Hall.

• Each historic district has its OWN ordinance created by property owners in the district and city staff together, according to federal guidelines.

• A structure of merit designation has the power to prevent demolition for only six months. The regulations DO NOT affect remodeling.

• All buildings are not created equal within a district — some are contributing and some are non-contributing, depending on their age and architectural or historical importance. Applications for changes to them are treated entirely differently.

• If you own a landmark, structure of merit, or district contributor, you are eligible to receive up to a 50 percent reduction in property taxes. This goes with the property so it can be an asset at the time of resale.

Many Santa Monica residents have been concerned about the rapid pace of demolition of older homes in our residentially-zoned neighborhoods, resulting in “mansionization” and loss of neighborhood character.

If an area qualifies for historic district status, the resulting neighborhood protections permit managed change — renovation, restoration and additions which preserve the original architectural quality and character.

You CAN have your cake and eat it too.

(Barbara Schnitzler is a member of the city’s landmark’s commission.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 2, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe