Skip to content

Short arm of the law prompts alien invasion

Published:

By CAROLE ORLIN

Like most Americans, I have been hearing endless news stories about illegal immigration and its strain on our cities, our schools, our health care systems and our homeland security.

The problem seems very simple. When you enter our country, you do so lawfully or you do so illegally. If you enter the United States or remain in the U.S. as an illegal immigrant, you are clearly breaking our laws. As an employer in this country, you are required by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services to complete a form (I-9), Employment Eligibility Verification, after being presented with acceptable documentation by each employee.

Despite the clearly defined laws and rules, like many Americans, I have been wondering why no significant changes in enforcement are working, only a change in the rhetoric, especially after “9/11”.

A number of recent articles have addressed some of my concerns. The first that caught my attention was entitled: “Go Back Where You Came From”, in the July 4, 2005 issue of Business Week magazine. The authors looked at a fast spreading grassroots backlash against Washington’s unwillingness or inability to deal with the ever-increasing number of illegal immigrants entering this country. The White House seems to be flip-flop-ping in its changing rhetoric about looking to highlight strict enforcement rather that an amnesty plan. Despite pleas from local officials about the use of tax dollars to provide welfare, education, health care and other benefits to illegals, there continues to be a new burst of illegal immigration in the U.S.

According to a new study by the Pew Hispanic Center in Washington, since 2000, 1.4 million Mexicans have come into the United States, and 85 percent of them have entered illegally.

Immigrants have become more sophisticated about entering our country. For example, Brazilians are entering the U.S. from Mexico this year at double the rate of 2004, according to the U.S. Border Patrol. The reason for this is that word has spread that any “OTM” (other than Mexican) entering the U.S. from the south will get a paper with a “notice to appear”, given an immigration hearing date several weeks away. Nine out of ten are “no shows” when the date arrives. The Border Patrol has voiced its frustration about the lack of space to detain those they do stop; convicted alien criminals mostly occupy the 94,000 beds reserved in federal detention facilities.

The Mayor of Fresno, Alan Aurty, has called for a two-year moratorium on all immigration, citing a “human tsunami” of illegal immigrants straining health and education services. The Mayor of Danbury Connecticut wants the state police to be deputized as federal immigration agents, as he stated city coffers are being drained by thousands of illegal aliens from Central and South America. Canyon County, Idaho Commissioner Robert Vasquez has sent Mexico an invoice for $2 million dollars to cover the cost of caring for illegal immigrants. He also plans to sue businesses that employ illegals, stating it is a violation of federal anti-racketeering laws. Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano has changed her stance and is now cutting public funding for day labor centers that cater to illegal immigrants.

These examples, along with the increased support grassroots organizations are receiving, reflect the growing frustration people feel as the government does nothing but change its rhetoric about this issue.

Business Week (July 18, 2005) followed this immigration theme with a cover story entitled “Embracing Illegals”. This article looks at the fact that big consumer companies (banks, mortgage lenders, phone companies, credit card companies, etc.) are highly enticed by a population of 11 million (although a recent study by Bear Stearns Asset Management company has concluded that there may be as many as 20 million illegal aliens in this country). Too big to ignore, the companies have decided to cater to them. Their rationale is simple: It may be against the law for them to be here, or for someone to hire them, but it’s not against the law to sell to them. Companies, like Kraft Foods Inc., will often not discuss the status of their customers, but admit they specifically target Hispanic newcomers. They provide workbooks at local ESL schools that include instructions for using coupons for products like Kraft’s Sun Drinks in grocery stores. Robert Simpson, Kraft’s multicultural marketing director stated: “We need to fish where the fish are.”

The list of big U.S. companies embracing illegals as consumers has intensified. Sprint, Blue Cross of California and a sister unit, Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Georgia, Verizon Communications, Inc.... the list of corporations lining up to serve illegal immigrants goes on and on.

An article from The Wall Street Journal (July 8, 2005) quotes James Smith, a Santa Monica senior economist at the RAND Corporation. Smith points to a fundamental contradiction in our policies. “We have one policy saying you can’t be here illegally. In practice, another policy is saying that if you’re here, we’re going to cater to you”.

An example of this is in Milwaukee, Wis., where the troubled Mitchell Bank, chaired by James Maloney (a labor attorney), saw an opportunity for profit by catering to their large, mostly illegal, Latino community by essentially redesigning his bank. He promoted his sole Hispanic employee to customer representative, and recruited many other Latinos. He had brochures and deposit slips written in Spanish, and even had a painting of Our Lady of Guadalupe — Mexico’s patron saint — displayed in the bank. He offered pamphlets on how to apply for a Wisconsin state ID and driver’s license and invited the Mexican consulate in Chicago to visit with a mobile unit that issues “matricula consular cards”, a form of identification issued by the Mexican government and often accepted by banks.

In 2002, Maloney began offering mortgages to illegal immigrants. Since most illegal immigrants do not have a credit history, he decided to consider rent, utility and overseas remittance receipts in assessing their ability to gain credit. In May, Maloney brought his plan to the Wisconsin Housing and Economic Development Authority. They agreed to finance the mortgages, as they felt it was is in keeping with their mission to help low-income families buy homes by offering mortgages at preferential interest rates that are fixed for 30 years. As a result, Mitchell Bank no longer retains the risk for loans. In the past four years, Mitchell Bank has approved about 100 home loans, mainly to illegal aliens. They say they have never issued a default, and needless to say, their business is booming. It is currently looking to open a new branch in Waukesha. A few lawmakers (like State Senator Glenn Grothman in Wisconsin) are upset and are taking the lead to nullify this type of program, highlighting the fact that the state should not be in the business of rewarding lawbreakers.

However, competition for new customers is driving banks (from small banks in Illinois, Texas, Iowa, and Ohio to the big players like Wells Fargo and Bank of America) to offer home loans and other financial services to illegal immigrants with help from government agencies like the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).

It has become obvious that the issue of illegal immigration will never be resolved based on what is legal or not, what is burdening our education, health care, welfare systems, or what is breaking the backs of middle class taxpayers. It’s simply all about the “Benjamin’s”. So the next time your children ask you why it’s OK for illegal immigrants to break the law, but it’s not OK for them to break the law, you can simply say: “My child, it’s all about the Benjamin’s.” (Carole).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 18, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe