Skip to content

Should there be a maximum driving age?

Published:

Ten people joined a 15-year-old Santa Monica girl killed five years ago by a 96-year -old driver who didn’t see her in the crosswalk.

Ten people died because after the 1998 accident, then-State Sen. Tom Hayden put in a bill to require an annual driving test for people over 75, but the AARP lobbied until the bill was gutted.

There’s a minimum driving age because we can’t rely upon the reflexes and decision-making ability of those under the age of 16. There should be a maximum driving age as well, for the exact same reasons.

It took George Russell Weller two blocks to realize that he had hit the accelerator instead of the brake. The last time he took a driving test was in 2000, and it was only a written test. Any other day, any non-farmers market day, he would probably have hit a light pole and we could have continued to ignore the problem.

But as baby boomers, the largest age group in the nation, head toward 60, we must face this problem now. (A side note: The City of Santa Monica isn’t free from blame in this horrible tragedy. There is no excuse for the fact that the street was closed by flimsy wooden barricades. There should have been cement pylons or other temporary but sturdy objects blocking the street.) The head of the ER at St. John’s Medical Center expressed no surprise at all. “We see an alarming number of older drivers losing control,” Dr. Russ Kino said last Wednesday.

There is a process for adults to report their aging parents’incapacity to drive, but the DMV’s massive bureaucracy stops the reporting process from being effective, with requests being lost in the paperwork for months. But this haphazard, piecemeal approach ignores the fact that drivers over 75 pose a danger to others on the road. “What about exceptions?” you ask. “My 80-year old aunt is fine behind the wheel.” I know a 15-year-old with the maturity to drive, but rules are rules.

There’s no shame in an 86-year-old in having their child or grandchild drive them places, or in taking the bus. It beats being led out of a police station. Or causing a funeral.

It’s going to take leadership and backbone and improved public transit. The legislature should encode a maximum driving age. This truly is homeland security — protecting California’s citizenry at home. It can’t be voluntary. It’s too late. (Evelyn Jerome is the founder and principal of Strategic Communications, a communications consulting firm. She is a past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 22, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe