Skip to content

Silverstein’s argument for war filled with holes

Published:

By Todd Work Santa Monica

Last week in response of Ed Silverstein’s periodic column on nothingness, I referred to him as a fence straddler who never took a side but, rather only criticized. Well, this week his column entitled “Off the fence,” states he is now off the fence and ready to go to war with Iraq. I had also refuted his opinion of local liberalism, by referring to some of the good people off Santa Monica as “altruistic” in their pursuit of grassroots endeavors toward change. Therefore I was both amused and dumb-founded to see that Mr. Silverstein used this same word but in a much different context. He states, “I am left with the impression that Bush’s key motivation is altruistic, as the President who used the might of the United States to bring about a safer world.”

To refer to George W. Bush as altruistic by waging war is a totally ludicrous. It is an oxymoron not unlike military-intelligence or Ed Silverstein-writer. He goes on to refer to this theory of harm against America as a justification for war with Iraq. He states, “He marched for peace against Vietnam but, this is a different kind of conflict.

Vietnam did not represent a threat to us Iraq does.” To wage lethal force on another person as a private citizen one would need a clear threat of imminent physical harm to ones self. Blacks Law Dictionary defines with relation to self defense, “Imminent danger is an immediate danger that cannot be guarded against; such as must be instantly met.”

Where is the imminent threat from Iraq? Whatever weapons Saddam has or does not have, the threat is no more imminent than it was a decade ago. This possible threat is, at best, to American interests abroad not to ourselves or to our dwelling homes. I could not legally kill someone for attempting to steal my bike chained to a fence out front of the apartment or for defiling my car in a parking lot because their is no imminent threat to my person, why then should I be able to drop bombs on people for some possible future threat to interests abroad?

Silverstein loves to use the buzz word terrorism and Saddam in the same sentence as if they are so easily interchangeable. Saddam Hussein is no doubt a ruthless dictator but the terrorism facing America today it seems is of a different sort. It is some misguided ideology whose embers smolder not unlike a fire fueled and fed by religious furor and American hatred. This hatred misguided or not stems from, among other things, our foreign policies abroad. You extinguish a fire by taking away its fuel and its oxygen, so why fan the flames of terrorism by waging a horrific war against a country that has as of yet, not given an immediate imminent threat to our person?

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 18, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe