By Tom Larmore
(Editor’s note: This is one of a series of weekly columns editorializing on the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses located in the coastal zone that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees up to $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded, which is before voters this November.
The Daily Press has asked organizers of Santa Monicans Allied for Responsible Tourism, which supports the living wage, to provide a counter-point opinion to balance out the debate. Those opinions will be printed each Friday until election day.) Supporters of Proposition JJ — the city’s minimum wage ordinance — have recently attempted to defend their position by referring to a study commissioned by the city two years ago and prepared by Robert Pollin of the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. The Pollin study, these folks contend, concludes that JJ will benefit local workers and can be implemented without harm to local businesses or the city. They also have said David Freeman of Harvard, one of the two “peer reviewers” of the Pollin report, supports these views.
Not surprisingly, there are several critical points which JJ advocates fail to mention about the Pollin study that make it irrelevant in this debate, even if you accept its conclusions as gospel instead of the politically-inspired fiction that it is. Most interesting is what the Pollin report says, and doesn’t say, about elements constituting the major flaws in JJ: Its coverage of tipped employees; its impact on the city budget; and its negative effect on our youth.
Tipped employees: One of the major problems with JJ, as I have pointed out in prior articles, is that it mandates a $12.25 minimum wage for tipped employees irrespective of their actual income. Businesses, such as restaurants and hotels, having employees who receive the bulk of their income from tips, typically pay them minimum wage (currently $6.75) or somewhat above that level, but less than $10.50. (In fact, tipped employees constitute the only class of workers being paid less than JJ requires by the purport-edly evil luxury hotels.) By requiring an increase of over 80 percent, JJ’s economic effect on restaurants is devastating.
Perhaps recognizing this problem, the Pollin report assumed that workers receiving at least one-half of their income from tips would be excluded. This means that only those minimum wage employees making less than $13.50 per hour, including tips, would be covered by the law. As the report says, “(We) interpret the intention of the City Council as seeking to increase the take-home pay, not the wages per se, of coastal zone workers.” As a result of this assumption, the Pollin report did not analyze the impact on businesses, including all tipped workers. Similarly, professor Freeman concluded that the tipped worker exemption was important to protect restaurants against excessive cost increases.
If an employee receives $6.75 per hour in tips, then the law essentially mandates that his or her income go from $13.50 to $19, soon to increase to almost $20! (And, of course, the effective minimum wage would be even higher as tips increase. It is not unusual for a waiter or waitress to earn $25 per hour or more from tips at a major restaurant, making the minimum wage $37.25!) Because labor costs constitute about one third of a restaurant’s sales, this increase would wipe out profits several times over. This is what leads restaurants, such as Ocean Avenue Seafood and P.F. Changs to seriously consider closing for lunch to keep below the $5 million sales threshold, thereby costing many people their jobs.
City employees: The Pollin study did not consider the effect of forcing the city to divert millions of dollars away from city services because, at the time his study was commissioned, no such provision was anticipated. Pollin was asked to consider the impact of the law on city residents and would certainly have looked at this issue had he been asked to do so.
As I pointed out earlier, one of the many differences between JJ and the typical “living wage” law is the inclusion of the city as a covered employer. While this element constitutes another of the major flaws in JJ, it is certainly not supported by the Pollin study.
Impact on youth: It is self-evident that employers who currently provide part-time or seasonal employment to teenagers will be unwilling to do so at wages of $12.25 or $13 per hour. Yet JJ requires covered employers, even nonprofit organizations, to pay wages at this level to all of its employees no matter their level of experience and irrespective of whether they are full-time or part-time. (One major retailer has told me that they will be forced to eliminate all part-time positions if JJ is approved. And don’t forget that each and every nonprofit organization that provides services funded by the city is covered by the law and, unless specifically exempted, will be required to pay all employees working on that contract the new minimum wage.) Americans have historically relied on experience and common sense to solve problems, appreciating methods that actually work rather than yielding to emotion, ideology or political, religious or scientific dogma. Adoption of JJ would, like Prohibition, be a major departure from that tradition — an effort to force into law an unworkable and counterproductive system in response to emotional and ideological slogans. (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a property rights attorney.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 17, 2002. Read the original PDF.